Sheepshead Bay
Most Popular Guides
Guide
The Best Restaurants In Sheepshead Bay
15 great spots for roast beef sandwiches, dim sum, old-fashioned donuts, and much more.
Sheepshead Bay
Sorted by most recent
NYCReview
Lucia Pizza of Avenue X
If you live near Lucia Pizza of Avenue X in Sheepshead Bay, make it your go-to spot for a grandma or vodka slice.
NYCReview
Roll N Roaster
Roll N Roaster is a fast food place in Sheepshead Bay that’s been around since 1971, and it specializes in roast beef sandwiches and melted cheese.
NYCGuide
The Best Restaurants In Sheepshead Bay
15 great spots for roast beef sandwiches, dim sum, old-fashioned donuts, and much more.
NYCReview
Randazzo's Clam Bar
Randazzo's Clam Bar is a Sheepshead Bay institution, specializing in Italian-American classics and seafood.
NYCReview
Cherry Hill Gourmet
Cherry Hill Gourmet is an Eastern European grocery store in Sheepshead Bay with a seemingly endless supply of products.
NYCReview
Safir Bakery & Cafe
Safir Bakery in Sheepshead Bay specializes in both sweet and savory Turkish baked goods
NYCReview
Carvel Ice Cream
The Carvel shop in Sheepshead Bay genuinely feels like it’s from another era, but with even better soft serve than we remember.
NYCReview
Long Wong Bakery II
Long Wong Bakery II makes our favorite egg and milk tarts in Sheepshead Bay.
NYCReview
Jimmy's Famous Heroes
Jimmy's Famous Heroes in Sheepshead Bay might just make the best Italian sandwiches in Brooklyn.
NYCReview
Shaikh’s Place
Shaikh’s Place is a classic donut shop in Sheepshead Bay where it’s far too easy to eat your weight in sweet treats.
NYCReview
Brennan & Carr
Brennan & Carr is a classic spot in Sheepshead Bay known for its roast beef sandwiches.