NYCReview

Cosme review image
8.7

Cosme

$$$$

35 E. 21st St, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

NYC’s Mexican food scene has come a long way since the early 2010s. And, much like the arrival of Instagram and Beyonce’s surprise album drop, Cosme helped change the game. Enrique Olvera, the famed Mexican chef behind a global restaurant empire including spots like Atla and Pujol, opened his first upscale restaurant in Manhattan with a purpose: to expand the way New York City diners perceive Mexican food. When Cosme officially opened in 2015, people who flip out about restaurants started flipping out.

On most nights, Cosme is filled with real estate tycoons and birthday groups wearing tailored blazers and high heels. From the paint on the walls to the massive pillars holding up the ceiling, every detail inside the restaurant is jet black, and there’s a dim spotlight above every table in the large room—a clever design choice that forces you to focus on the thick menus outlining the food you’re about to receive.

Cosme’s menu lists its dishes as rows of ingredients that change with the seasons. Snack your way through a medley of grilled octopus tostadas, esquites with crab, and a potato tetela topped with caviar—and be sure to save room for the duck carnitas. This unmissable plate involves half of a juicy, roasted duck served in a cast-iron pan, paired with warm tortillas so you can make your own tender taco feast. Sharing this top-notch dish with one or two other people (and ordering a few rounds of mezcal margaritas) is the kind of power move that’ll make you want to revisit Cosme on a monthly basis. Olivera's first-ever Manhattan restaurant is still an ideal place to dress up and eat a special occasion meal in Flatiron, especially if you've ever fantasized about perfectly-prepared heirloom corn tortillas. This might not be the only hot spot serving scallop tostadas with nopal anymore—but it’s still the most exciting. Even if you have to make up a reason to celebrate something here (your cat’s half-birthday, perhaps), book a table and start planning a subtly luxurious outfit. You’ll be happy you did.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Food Rundown

Cosme review image

Uni Tostada, Avocado, Bone Marrow Salsa, Cucumber

Thank you, Mexico, for giving us the gift of this glorious tostada. As a gesture of gratitude, we’d like to give you Arizona and Texas back.

Cosme review image

Stuffed Avocado, Seafood Vuelve A La Vida, Horseradish

Considering the fact that avocado toast is pretty much the national breakfast these days, it’s surprising we haven’t seen more stuffed avocado in the US. Maybe we’re just not that creative. Do it up.

Cosme review image

Cobia Al Pastor

White fish done in the classic al pastor style and served with Cosme’s incredible housemade tortillas. This presents another great opportunity to make your own tacos and feel proud of yourself for doing so.

Cosme review image

Duck Carnitas

If there’s one thing you need to order here, it's the $98 plate of duck carnitas. The massive dish involves half of a juicy roasted duck served in a cast-iron pan and paired with warm tortillas, so you can make your own taco feast. Stop by and share it with a few friends the next time you earn a degree, have a birthday to celebrate, or decide to spend the rest of your life with someone.

Cosme review image

Mushroom And Squash Barbacoa

Not looking to eat a duck at dinner? This mushroom and squash dish is a great option for vegetarians and ’shroom enthusiasts alike.

Featured in

18 Brunch Spots For Special Occasions guide image
Guide
18 Brunch Spots For Special Occasions

NYC restaurants that feel fancy enough for a special occasion meal involving pancakes and Bloody Marys.

The Best Mexican Restaurants In NYC guide image
Guide
The Best Mexican Restaurants In NYC

Our 29 favorite Mexican restaurants in NYC.

The Best Restaurants For Special Occasions In NYC guide image
Guide
The Best Restaurants For Special Occasions In NYC

From a Japanese spot that lets guests pick the soundtrack to a Middle Eastern restaurant that's ideal for big groups, here are the best places to celebrate something in NYC.

A Venezuelan Arepa Expert’s Favorite NYC Hispanic & Latinx Spots guide image
Guide
A Venezuelan Arepa Expert’s Favorite NYC Hispanic & Latinx Spots

Mercedes Golip shares her favorite places to find carnitas, tequeños, and more.

Suggested Reading

Little Park review image
Review
Little Park

A Tribeca restaurant from Andrew Carmellini that belongs on your Hit List, if not your bucket list.

The Clocktower review image
Review
The Clocktower

The Clocktower in the Edition Hotel is a Flatiron facsimile of a popular restaurant in London. And it works here just as well as it works over there.

Javelina review image
Review
Javelina

Some say that Javelina is the first true arrival of Tex-Mex in New York City. We're not that excitable.

Atla review image
8.3
Review
Atla

Atla serves excellent Mexican food in a bright, all-day space in Noho. It’s great for a casual lunch or an upscale dinner.