NYCReview

Smyth Tavern review image
6.2

Smyth Tavern

$$$$

85 W Broadway, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points
RESERVE A TABLE

POWERED BY

open table

This restaurant is from the team behind Lure Fishbar, which has one of the best burgers in the city. So it’s no surprise that the burger at Smyth Tavern, with its bacon onion jam mixed with melty American cheese, is something you’ll want to tell your friends about. However, not much else here is worth mentioning. Sliders made with deep-fried branzino have no detectable salt and taste too fishy, and the veal chop milanese is overcooked, dry, and equally as bland. The mafaldine with uni butter and lobster should be an easy win, but it’s borderline inedible due to all the overpowering lemon juice squeezed into it. This restaurant is convenient if you’re staying at the adjacent Smyth Tribeca Hotel. But unless there’s a blizzard or a hurricane, we suggest venturing out and hitting up one of the many better spots in the neighborhood.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Featured in

The 8 Best New Burgers In NYC guide image
Guide
The 8 Best New Burgers In NYC

Eight burgers you’ll be hearing about a whole lot moving forward.

Suggested Reading

Tiny's and the Bar Upstairs review image
Review
Tiny's and the Bar Upstairs

Tiny's and the Bar Upstairs is located in its own three-story, pastel pink townhouse in Tribeca. It's a cute place, and you should eat a burger here.

Au Cheval review image
8.0
Review
Au Cheval

The original Au Cheval in Chicago makes one of our all-time favorite burgers, and the location in Tribeca serves a damn good one as well.

Frenchette review image
9.1
Review
Frenchette

Frenchette is a French brasserie in Tribeca with an energetic room and a constantly-changing menu of rich dishes.

The Best Restaurants In Tribeca guide image
Guide
The Best Restaurants In Tribeca

Burgers, sushi, tasting menus, and more.