NYCReview

Maialino is permanently closed

Maialino review image

Maialino

$$$$

2 Lexington Ave, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

Much like a Damian Lillard playoff performance or any A24 horror movie, a meal at Maialino in Gramercy hardly ever lets us down. Since they’re in the Gramercy Park Hotel, you can effectively stop by at any time of day for a consistently excellent meal - they serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and if you show up at an odd hour, you can snack on some suppli and spicy Calabrian chile duck wings while you drink a spritz. The Roman pastas, like a creamy carbonara or a cacio e pepe made with the slightly-thicker-than-spaghetti tonarelli, are always cooked perfectly al dente. The pastries and desserts are ever-changing, but are consistently buttery and delicious (we miss you, olive oil cake that we spent years trying to recreate). We’ve celebrated multiple special occasions here and taken pretty much our whole family to this restaurant, but you don’t need a special occasion to have a bowl of pasta and a cocktail at Maialino.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Food Rundown

Suppli Al Telefono

A bar menu-only item that’s basically arancini, but with tomato risotto and mozzarella inside. They’re excellent and guaranteed to be so hot inside that you burn the sht out of your mouth.

Carciofini Fritti

A fairly standard order of tiny fried artichokes - we’re never mad about eating them, but they won’t be the star of your table, either.

Tonnarelli Cacio E Pepe

A very simple long Roman noodle with cheese and black pepper. This is one of our favorite things to eat at Maialino.

Maialino review image

Bucatini All’Amatriciana

This amazing bucatini is perfectly al dente and sits in a spicy tomato sauce with pork jowl.

Maialino review image

Maialino Al Forno

This is the Maialino specialty - a big piece of crispy-skinned pork that serves anywhere between three and five. It’s a large hunk of meat, and it’s good, but we prefer the pastas and the brunch items here.

Brioche Caramellato

Toffee-glazed brioche. You are going to want two of these, even after you eat a heavy brunch.

Poached Egg And Porchetta Sandwich

An Italian breakfast sandwich that can rival any BEC or pork roll out there.

Torta Della Nonna

Our favorite dessert (though the bread pudding is awesome, too), this is a lemon tart with pine nuts. So good.

Featured in

Where To Eat In Gramercy guide image
Guide
Where To Eat In Gramercy

If you find yourself in Gramercy, here are the best restaurants in the area.

Where To Have A Meeting Downtown guide image
Guide
Where To Have A Meeting Downtown

If you need to grab some daytime food and have a conversation with someone south of Midtown, these are your best options.

Where To Have A Graduation Lunch Or Dinner guide image
Guide
Where To Have A Graduation Lunch Or Dinner

30 restaurants to visit when the speeches are over.

Where To Book Dinner For Your Boss guide image
Guide
Where To Book Dinner For Your Boss

Places to reserve a table for the person who signs your paychecks.

Suggested Reading

Gramercy Tavern review image
8.3
Review
Gramercy Tavern

Don't take this fine dining restaurant by Union Square as seriously as it takes itself. Instead, treat Gramercy Tavern as a fun neighborhood spot where you can eat a fantastic burger at the bar.

Il Buco Alimentari e Vineria review image
Review
Il Buco Alimentari e Vineria

The Italian food at Noho’s Il Buco Alimentari e Vineria has the honor of being among the only things in history to improve after a key lineup change.

Osteria Morini review image
Review
Osteria Morini

Osteria Morini is a popular Italian restaurant on Lafayette street, known for pasta and lots of lambrusco. Expect crowds and very little elbow room.

Craftbar review image
Review
Craftbar

Craftbar in Union Square is an excellent, casual restaurant in an area that needs more excellent, casual restaurants.