CHIGuide

Are These Chicago Restaurants Worth The Hype?

Find out whether the spots you're always hearing about are worth your time and money.
Are These Chicago Restaurants Worth The Hype?  image

photo credit: Allison Gallese

People generally fall into two categories when it comes to a hyped-up restaurant. They either have a primal instinct to experience it as soon as possible, or, they deem it overrated, despite never having been. Either way, you know you want to know:

Is this restaurant worth it?

Chicago has a lot of these restaurants. Places with elaborate tableside gymnastics trending on TikTok. Overexposed classics your cousin in Florida knows about for some reason. Restaurants that you keep hearing about. Again. And again. And….again. Some are good, some are not, and some are fun enough that it doesn’t matter. So before you decide to wait in line or make that 4pm dinner reservation, consult this guide.

THE SPOTS

photo credit: Jeff Marini

American

West Loop

$$$$Perfect For:Date NightDinner with the ParentsImpressing Out of TownersLiterally EveryoneSmall Plates
Earn 3x points with your sapphire card

The Verdict: Eat here once and you'll become a regular.

Maxwells Trading in West Loop has only been open since the start of 2024 but it’s already challenging to get a reservation (don’t worry, we have you covered). Understandable since the fusion-y dishes—like fazzoletti with lamb and chili crisp—are all good, and at least a third of them are incredible. Inside this brick building that reads more “art gallery” than “failed startup headquarters,” vinyl records are played loud enough to be fun, but not so loud you have to scream. Along with Monteverde (also on this guide) and Daisies, Maxwells has become one of our go-to spots for when someone comes in from out of town. The scallion pancakes with french onion dip will make them brag about their visit, but so will the strong martinis and warm service.

photo credit: John Ringor

RESERVE A TABLE

POWERED BY

OpenTable logo

The Verdict: Do whatever you need to do to get in.

It’s not surprising that this Logan Square spot has been packed the minute since opening. Its owner, a Redditor-turned-chef known as "Ramen_Lord", has a large following and his past pop-ups sold out instantly. But eating is believing—bowls of rich and creamy Akahoshi Miso and soupless tantanmen flavored with tingly Sichuan peppercorns are delicious and worth racing to grab a spot at a booth or the communal table. Chances are, reservations are all booked when you’re done reading this. But they allow walk-ins, so you can probably snag a spot if you get there before they open at 5pm.

photo credit: Costera Cocina Tulum

RESERVE A TABLE

POWERED BY

OpenTable logo

The Verdict: An aggressively theme-y clubstaurant that’s a solid spot for drinks.

Do straw, palm trees, and enough rope to fund a legion of double-dutch teams make you think of Tulum? Costera, a Mexican spot from the team behind Nisos, hopes so. This Fulton Market clubstaurant has all the markers of a place you visit to loudly drunk-laugh while shelling out $48 for al pastor flambéed tableside that no one eats because it tastes like sweet onion jam. The real draws here are the tasty fruit-forward drinks and being surrounded by people enjoying their flame-topped margaritas in a tiki glass.

The Verdict: Unless you’re the Guinness equivalent of a Disney World adult, just grab a pint at one of the many Irish pubs in the city.

A sign saying “The Wait Is Over” hangs outside Guinness Brewery in West Loop, but the line of people waiting for an hour says otherwise. Sure, the head-to-beer ratio of the pours meets Official Guinness Handbook standards. But the large space is full of out-of-towners and feels like a chain restaurant for tourists. The branding is inescapable, from the wall with the founder’s giant signature to a massive harp floating above the bar. There’s even a gift shop and bakery with Guinness-infused bread. The food menu is eclectic, with average burgers, stews, and udon (how’d that get on there?)—and they’re mainly beer buffers.

photo credit: Kim Kovacik

The Verdict: Most definitely worth the wait. In fact, this New American spot recently made our list of 25 Best Restaurants In Chicago.

Limited hours. No reservations. An unpredictable menu. Warlord opened in May with little information beyond the above, which we normally consider red flags. But we can now tell you that the line out the door isit’s worth the wait. And since they're open until 2am, that wait can be a pretty long one. The menu changes everyday, which is both exciting—"This ramp pasta is incredible!"—and bittersweet—"Will I ever see these miso butter scallops again?" Warlord is playing hard to get, but that only makes us want this spot even more.

The Verdict: Only good for dessert and a view.

This Japanese restaurant is on the rooftop of the $700-a-night St. Regis Hotel in Lakeshore East. The view of the skyline is incredible, but the most of the food isn’t. The long menu runs the gamut, from just-OK sushi to not-good-at-all entrees like burnt miso cod. So unless you happen to be staying here and have extra money to throw off said rooftop, it’s not worth the price. The desserts actually tend to be pretty good though, so stick to those—the view is better if you’re not distracted by mushy duck yakisoba.

The Verdict: A mid-century theme that actually works.

This Italian steakhouse on the edge of Fulton Market is working hard at channeling mid-century-era glamour, complete with bartenders in waistcoats and a checkered marble floor. But instead of men in power suits flagging down a dessert trolley in a stuffy dining room, diners wearing tech vests order the tableside Caesar salad cart at the bar. There are excellent steaks on the menu—like an olive-fed wagyu New York strip that will make you wonder whether that cow had its own personal masseuse. There are also tasty 4oz plates of housemade pasta if potatoes aren't special enough to accompany your $165 steak.

The Verdict: Bypass the restaurant and go have a drink on the roof. Collect $200 (of money, that you have now saved).

Nobus are ubiquitous in major cities, and Chicago’s very own is in the West Loop, at the bottom of the (you guessed it) Nobu Hotel. It has an identical Japanese fusion menu to its brethren, and nothing is mindblowing. What is mindblowing is the bill—especially for just-fine food and an unpredictable dining experience that might have you surrounded by tables filled with sulking couples, MMA fighters on their phones, recent grads celebrating with their parents, and an ever-growing pile of dirty dishes the staff is too busy to clear. Instead of coming here for dinner, head to the elevators and go up to the much-more-fun rooftop bar.

The Verdict: Yep. Kasama is one of the best restaurants in Chicago.

This small cafe-by-day, fine-dining-by-night spot in West Town has the only Filipino tasting menu in the city, and reservations for the $235 dinner are almost impossible to snag. Daytime is just as mobbed—the line for breakfast pastries forms before they even open at 9am. The droves are warranted when delicately laminated danishes are basically meditation in pastry form. And at night, each tasting-menu course is delicate without being too precious. Mushroom adobo is served alongside a frothy mussel emulsion. Consider it your solemn duty to come here. We don’t care how dramatic that sounds.

The Verdict: Obelix made our list of Best New Restaurants Of 2022, so, yes, we think it’s worth the hype. 

The hype surrounding this River North spot has been of the slow-burn variety. It didn’t open to much fanfare in the summer of 2022, but has steadily become one of the most sought-after dinner reservations in town. On the surface, Obelix looks like a typical, white-tablecloth French restaurant. It’s not. Obelix walks the tightrope of feeling formal without being stuffy. And that same balance is present in the food, which is filled with a mixture of classics like escargot and playful, fusion-y things like a foie gras taco. 

The Verdict: Come here if you’re looking for someone with access to a boat, or are someone who pretends to have a boat.

This Greek spot is a party restaurant, infamous for TikTok-ready tableside preparations, and an 11pm weekend “ritual” where servers dance on tables with sparklers and everyone waves napkins around to clubby Greek music. The food is hit-or-miss, but it’s also probably not the reason you’re here. You’re here for ouzo-fueled shout-talking and to brag about scoring an invite to a yacht this summer. There is a selection of spreads that are just fine, and an overly acidic tuna tartare that’s too wet. But the “tableside gyros" are tasty enough that you're able to move past the fact that the dish is really just lamb shoulder that a server listlessly shreds with a fork. It’s all pretty expensive though, so you should only come here if you want to be somewhere buzzy while surrounded by an absurd amount of wicker lampshades.

The Verdict: The rumors are true, it’s worth the hype.

Google “Monteverde” and try to make a reservation for some time over the next month. Did you hear that? That was Resy laughing at you. This is the best Italian restaurant in Chicago, and the first place we try (and often fail) to make reservations when someone from the East Coast tells us they're visiting. The menu is full of hits, from cacio e pepe to the ragu alla Napoletana—a tomato-braised pork shank with three soppressata meatballs, two cacciatore sausages, and a pile of fusilli we want buried with us when we die.

photo credit: Matthew Gilson

POWERED BY

Tock logo

Access exclusive reservations with your sapphire reserve card

Sapphire Reserve

The Verdict: Yes, if you can avoid social media spoilers—luckily Alinea is too old to be trending on TikTok.

Everyone knows Alinea. Since its 2005 opening it’s been on countless worldwide “Best” lists, featured in documentaries, and helped fuel the aughts’ obsession with liquid nitrogen and eating stuff that looked like other stuff. And despite what Hot Take Harry tells you, dinner here is still an incredible time. The almost $500 per person dinner at Alinea is a delicious experience (think fog machines and edible napkins) and there’s nothing quite like it. Accept no substitutions. 

The Verdict: We’d like to be eating at Bavette’s right now. 

This dark steakhouse (filled with plush leather booths and 1920s jazz music) is like hanging out in the windowless parlor of some old money mansion. Everything about the River North space seems designed to keep you there forever, which might explain why tables are never available—no one leaves. Some of our favorite dishes here (like the fried chicken, chocolate cream pie, and complimentary bread—yes it’s that good) aren’t even steak at all. And drinking Old Fashioneds in a room that makes you feel like a character in Clue is objectively fun. 

The Verdict: This is a great restaurant that’s worth your time. 

Rose Mary has been hyped up since before it even opened during summer 2021. We blame it on this large Croatian spot’s combination of being in the West Loop and having a Top Chef winner in the kitchen. It’s so hyped, in fact, that you’ll hear people claim that the food here isn’t even any good. That is untrue. The Croatian food is consistently delicious, and the service is always top-notch. The crni rizot is what the ocean would taste like if it made a wish to become risotto. There’s a plate of garlicky cevapi perfect for sharing, and incredible pastas too. Despite the busyness of this place, you’ll always be seated in a timely fashion, and have a relaxed dinner with clairvoyant servers who bring the check exactly when you’re ready to leave. 

The Verdict: Not reinventing the wheel, but book a table and wear those cute new shoes that hurt your feet.

Any Chicago restaurant associated with the words “West Loop,” “Italian,” and “Boka Restaurant Group” is guaranteed to be hyped. This is the case with Alla Vita, an Italian BCR on Randolph.  It’s designed to be a crowd-pleaser, buzzing with everyone from couples to large groups in town for some investment conference. It’s also pretty, decorated with hanging plants and an intriguing overhead installation that looks a little like fish gills. And while the menu isn’t going to blow your mind with creativity (it’s mainly pizza, pasta, and a handful of entrees) what’s on it is good. The pizza has a chewy wood-fired crust, and the silky cacio e pepe ricotta dumplings will have you waving a spoon in the air like a 2000s Yoplait commercial. 

The Verdict: Don’t come here just for the burger. 

You’re probably aware that the Au Cheval burger is good—the 673 people standing expectantly outside the all-day restaurant right now can’t be completely wrong. The question is just how good one burger can possibly be? And should you spend three hours in a line that has stretched outside and around the corner since 2012? You shouldn’t…unless you also order dishes like the duck heart hash, chilaquiles, and towering mille-feuille. It’s the rest of this diner’s menu (along with a very good burger) that make Au Cheval one place you’ll still be waiting for no matter what time of day you show up. The food is, and always has been, worth it.

Chase Sapphire Card Ad

Suggested Reading

The front dining room at Maxwells Trading with wooden tables and a bar on the right side

The Toughest Reservations In Chicago Right Now (And How To Get Them)

Our thoughts on the most exclusive restaurants in Chicago and advice on how to get a table.

The Best Restaurants In River North image

River North

There’s a lot going on in this neighborhood, and deciding on a restaurant can be tough. This is where you should be eating.

The dining room at Maxwells Trading with wooden tables and large windows on the left side

Our favorite places in the neighborhood. Yes, this includes Monteverde.

Infatuation Logo

Company

2024 © The Infatuation Inc. All Rights Reserved.

FIND PLACES ON OUR APP

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store