After trying Upside’s cheese slice from their new Soho location that’s made with sourdough, we might be ready to say goodbye to Joe’s as our de facto NYC slice recommendation. The dough from Upside is noticeably tangy, the cheese stays put, and there are patches of bubbly caramelized cheese that make us thankful for fire. The square slices shouldn’t be missed, especially their cheese-less Sicilian that’s covered in thin slices of garlic, crisped up basil leaves, and perfectly seasoned tomato sauce that’s zesty and not too sweet.

Featured in

The 24 Best Pizza Places In NYC guide image
The 24 Best Pizza Places In NYC

The top 24 pizzas in NYC, according to us.

Suggested Reading

Ace’s Perfect Pizza review image
Ace’s Perfect Pizza

Ace’s in Williamsburg is where you should go for the best Detroit-style pizza in the city.

Leo review image

Leo is one of the best pizza places in Brooklyn, especially if you’re into sourdough pies and natural wine.

Joe’s Pizza FiDi review image
Joe’s Pizza FiDi

This is the FiDi location of the iconic slice shop.

Scarr’s Pizza review image
Scarr’s Pizza

Scarr’s is a retro slice shop on the Lower East Side with some excellent pizza and a pretty lively scene.