Come for the fresh pasta, stay for the private garden that you’ll immediately want to move into. We go to Tutto Il Giorno (which now has a few locations throughout the Hamptons) for one of two reasons: a big meal before a night out, or to drink some wine after checking out the stores in town. Either way, it’s a Southampton staple that we find ourselves coming back to time and time again thanks to its reliable food (the spicy tuna tartare is a must) and casual feel.

David A. Lee