River Cafe review image

River Cafe

$$$$(718) 522 7133

If you want to take the '90s revival trend and translate it to your next nice dinner, you might as well do so at the River Cafe. The food at this special-occasion spot in Dumbo is prepared well, even if it’s a bit uninspired—but the real draw is the picturesque view from the main dining room, which is as close to eating in the East River as you can get.

Dinner is a fixed-price three-course situation, and the appetizers are by far the most interesting. We especially love the retro feel of the wagyu steak tartare, which is mixed tableside by one of several waiters who attend your table during your meal. (If there’s one thing besides the view that’s a real standout, it’s the service.) Mains like duck and black sea bass are enjoyable, even if they taste as though the top graduate of a very boring culinary school prepared them for their final exam. The desserts, sadly, are a miss. 

But you’re not really at the River Cafe to have exciting food. You’re here to celebrate your 85-year-old grandpa’s birthday, propose to someone, or simply revel in the strangeness of watching kindergarteners in Gucci polo shirts toss back mocktails. Servers in matching cropped white jackets will perform a choreographed dance to simultaneously drop plates on your table as you gaze out at the Manhattan skyline, feeling fancy. The other thing we love about the River Cafe? The garden. It looks like it was airlifted from a Thomas Kincaid painting, complete with fairy lights in every tree. 

Featured in

The Best Restaurants In Dumbo and Brooklyn Heights guide image
The Best Restaurants In Dumbo and Brooklyn Heights

There's more to these neighborhoods than overpriced tourist traps.

Where To Dress Up And Not Feel Stupid guide image
Where To Dress Up And Not Feel Stupid

If you're looking for a place to wear that sample sale piece sitting in the back of your closet, try one of these restaurants.

Suggested Reading

Vinegar Hill House review image
Vinegar Hill House

One of our favorite restaurants in Brooklyn, especially in the summer when their back garden is in full swing. Bring some bug spray, eat a pork chop.

Colonie review image

Colonie is one of the best restaurants in Brooklyn Heights for brunch or dinner.

Henry's End review image
Henry's End

A Brooklyn Heights stand-by with upscale, old-fashioned food.