Red Hook Tavern is from the same people behind Hometown Bar-B-Que, the single best place to get barbecue in NYC. It’s also in Red Hook, but it’s a different sort of operation modeled on old-school bars and steakhouses like Corner Bistro and Peter Luger. It’s just one long room with brick walls and vintage-looking light fixtures, and it feels exactly like the kind of place where you’d want to have a mug of beer and burger. And that’s exactly what you should do here. The burger is salty and buttery with some melted American cheese and a big patty that’s surprisingly light, and it’s worth a trip from another borough. There’s also an excellent steak with a salty charred crust (and a side of creamed spinach that almost tastes healthy), as well as a romaine wedge salad that comes with a thick slab of some extremely good bacon. Stop in and grab a seat at the bar (where it’s walk-in-only), or make a reservation and have a heavy and rewarding dinner with a couple of people who appreciate red meat.
More spots in Red HookSee more
Although they’re known for their libations at Fort Defiance, this restaurant doesn’t feel like one of those super-cool, pretentious cocktail dens that we all know too well. It has the promise of the perfect neighborhood spot that, if we lived in this hood, we’d frequent all the time.
More American spotsSee more
If you live near Walter Foods, you come here a lot. I guess if we lived near Walter Foods, we would too.
Union Square Cafe
Union Square Cafe is a classic New York City restaurant having its second life in a new space. The good news? It’s still as good as ever.
Suggested by our writers
Peter Luger Steak House
Peter Luger is a New York City steakhouse institution, and eating here is an experience unlike any other in the city.
The best BBQ in New York City resides in Red Hook, in a Texas-style dining hall of sacred smoked meats known as Hometown Bar-B-Que.
Brooklyn Crab is one of the most unique outdoor dining destinations in NYC for two reasons: crabs and mini golf.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more