A Guide To Black-Owned NYC Bakeries & Sweets Shops guide image


A Guide To Black-Owned NYC Bakeries & Sweets Shops

Pastry chef and author Jeremiah Josey gives his top picks for his favorite Black-owned bakeries and sweet shops in the city.

Though he’s only 22 years old, Jeremiah Josey has already accomplished a lot. He’s worked alongside chefs like Kwame Onwuachi, Marcus Samuelsson, and Christina Tosi. Josey is also diagnosed as autistic, and along with his mother Simone Greggs, wrote a children’s book on autism, Here’s What I Want You to Know. He’s writing a second book, this one about the Black Lives Matter movement. And somewhere in there, he found time to walk the runway at New York Fashion Week.

“I think what the restaurant industry might not understand about individuals with autism is that it’s just way different [for us],” explains Josey. “The pace and the way we work is different. The restaurant industry might require things a certain way and [people] don’t realize it can be a little different for individuals with disabilities, in terms of pace and everything of the sort.”

A Guide To Black-Owned NYC Bakeries & Sweets Shops guide image

photo credit: Jamie Cheyenne

Although currently based in Maryland, Josey hopes to one day permanently relocate to New York, a city he has been to “countless times,” and whose pastry shops he loves and admires. Here are some of his favorite Black-owned bakeries and shops in the city.

The Spots

Make My Cake imageoverride image

Make My Cake


2380 Adam Clayton Powell Jr Blvd, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

The Harlem bakery serves apple turnovers, sweet potato pies, and excellent croissants. It’s owned and operated by Aliyyah Baylor, whom Josey collaborated with a few years ago on a “cooking adventure” video released on the young pastry chef’s own YouTube channel. “Harlem is known for its history, music, and great food,” says Josey. “So I was honored when Aliyyah accepted my request to work together.”

Sisters Courtney Blagrove and Zan B.R. own the ice cream shop on Orchard Street, which also offers plant-based, vegan, and dairy-free options—including one of Josey’s favorites, the cinnamon apple crisp featuring a dairy-, egg-, nut-, soy-, and gluten-free base. “Released in honor of Juneteenth, the shop’s ‘Taste of Freedom’ oat milk ice cream flavor is a whole new level of deliciousness,” says Josey. “One day I hope to have a bakery, and I would love to learn from Courtney and Zan how to best serve healthy options.” Expect a line.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.

By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Josey’s own signature dish is cheesecake (he uses his grandmother’s recipe), which makes Kym Rodgers’ shop his “happy place.” “I love the fact that, at Brooklyn Sweet Spot, they offer cheesecake jars.” he adds.

The custom cake shop in Prospect Heights has served the likes of Rihanna, Jay-Z, and Taraji P. Henson, among other notable customers. “As I think about the future, it would be great to have a few celebrity clients,” muses Josey. But that’s not the only reason he visits the bakery. “I love their focus on cake design,” he says. “They offer a ton of signature options. One of my favorites is the art collage cake, which is perfect for designer brand prints and allows you to personalize your cake. I also really like the custom Juneteenth cake!”

Founded by Craig Watson and Eddie Figueroa, the bakery with locations in East Harlem and the East Village sells 100 percent nut-free and kosher treats. Josey’s favorite is the lava cupcake—a chocolate cake garnished and baked with semi-sweet chocolate.

Chase Sapphire Card Ad

Suggested Reading

Can You Still Get A Great Egg Cream In NYC? guide image
Can You Still Get A Great Egg Cream In NYC?

Our search for the best egg creams in NYC.

Inside Ruffian’s Expanded Space: The Tiny East Village Wine Bar Just Got A Little Bigger feature image

After five years, our favorite East Village wine bar is taking over the space next door, offering a new oyster menu and private dining.

What It’s Like Running An NYC Restaurant When You Don’t Speak English feature image

How the pandemic has changed an already challenging situation for non-English-speaking restaurant owners.

200+ Black-Owned Restaurants Across NYC feature image

Our running list of Black-owned spots in NYC.

Infatuation Logo
2023 © The Infatuation Inc. All Rights Reserved.


Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store