Make My Cake - Harlem - New York - The Infatuation

NYCReview

Make My Cake review image

Make My Cake

Perfect For:BirthdaysKidsSerious Take-Out Operation

$$$$

2380 Adam Clayton Powell Jr Blvd, New York

View Website Earn 3X Points

Hannah Albertine

Hannah AlbertineNovember 12, 2020

In addition to cakes and cupcakes, this Black-owned bakery on Adam Clayton Powell Jr Boulevard also sells cookies, sweet potato pies, apple turnovers, blueberry cobblers, and lemon meringue pie you can pre-order for pick-up or delivery. Check out their page here to submit your order. They also do wedding cakes and special orders.

If you’re closer to 116th than you are to 139th Street, know that Make My Cake also has a location there.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.

Featured in

Where To Preorder Thanksgiving Pies In NYC guide image

Guide

Where To Preorder Thanksgiving Pies In NYC

Thanksgiving may not go as planned. At least there’s pie.

A Guide To Black-Owned NYC Bakeries & Sweets Shops guide image

Guide

A Guide To Black-Owned NYC Bakeries & Sweets Shops

Pastry chef and author Jeremiah Josey gives his top picks for his favorite Black-owned bakeries and sweet shops in the city.

Suggested Reading

Mel review image

Review

Mel

Lower East Side

Mel is a bakery on the LES that makes some excellent sourdough bread and chocolate croissants.

Patisserie des Ambassades review image

Review

Patisserie des Ambassades

SenegaleseWest African•

Les Ambassades is a Senegalese spot in Harlem where you should sit outside before or after getting a pastry from their bakery next door.

Pikine review image

Review

Pikine

SenegaleseWest African•

Pikine is one of the best West African restaurants in Harlem.

Melba’s review image

8.3

Review

Melba’s

Melba’s is a spot in Harlem with some great fried chicken, catfish, and waffles. Try it for a casual meal, and get a side of mac and cheese.