By day, Big Mario’s is one of the more reliable New York-style slice joints in Seattle, even though the red sauce is a little on the spicier side. By 2am, Big Mario’s is a sloppier sh*tshow mess than your high school’s salutatorian at the Senior Prom. It’s where to go to grab a quick lunch or a pie for the group to take back to your place, but also where to go when you’ve had eight drinks at Sam’s Tavern and tearing through an obscene amount of late-night pizza is your ultimate mission. Just keep in mind, that’s what the rest of the hammered pizza-craving zombie people had in mind too. Be prepared to wait for a long time after midnight, but there’s nothing like a Mario’s pepperoni slice to soak up all of that Manny’s you ruthlessly chugged.
Where we've featured it
More spots in Capitol HillSee more
Cedars in Capitol Hill
Cedars In Capitol Hill is a great takeout option for Indian or Mediterranean food. Get the butter chicken.
Dingfelder’s is a New York-style deli in Capitol Hill that serves sandwiches out of a takeout window.
Dino’s Tomato Pie
Dino’s is one of few places in Seattle that knows how to do New York pizza. It’s one of our favorite spots in Cap Hill for dinner and drinks.
More Pizza spotsSee more
Petoskey’s Pizza is a fun spot in Fremont that feels like a restaurant you might find in the Midwest.
Serious Pie has two locations, but we like the one in Belltown best. Use it for date night or a group dinner, and get as many pizzas as possible.
Suggested by our writers
Bar Del Corso
Bar Del Corso, a classic Beacon Hill Italian spot, should be your first choice for Neapolitan pizza in the city.
Supreme is a West Seattle pizzeria with New York-style pies and slices, plus boozy slushies and excellent garlic knots.
Frēlard Pizza Company
Want to have an adult pizza party? With beer? On a patio? Frēlard in Fremont is your move.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more