photo credit: Kenny Yang

Pick-A-Bagel review image


$$$$(212) 517-6590

If you live in Paris, one of the perks is being able to get amazing croissants at countless boulangeries. For New Yorkers, the same is true, but for bagels. The problem with this location of Pick-A-Bagel on 77th and Lex is that you’re just not sure what you’re going to get. One bagel in a batch might be fresh and chewy, while another might be hard and taste like it’s been sitting out for at least a day. Also, their version of an everything bagel has such sparse seasoning that you’ll wonder if they gave you another kind by mistake. If you live within walking distance of this place, it’ll probably do. You can find all the expected bagel shop things here like smoked fish, house sandwiches, and a bunch of cream cheese varieties. But why risk it? You’re better off spending a little extra time heading to one of the many truly great spots in the city.

Suggested Reading

Absolute Bagels review image
Absolute Bagels

Absolute Bagels on the Upper West Side makes our favorite bagels in all of New York City. Bring cash and get a Thai iced tea.

Pastrami Queen review image
Pastrami Queen

Pastrami Queen makes some of our favorite sandwiches on the Upper East Side.

The Best Bagels In NYC guide image
The Best Bagels In NYC

It’s easy to find a good bagel in NYC. But a great one? You’ll find those in this guide.

The Best Brunch On The Upper East Side guide image
The Best Brunch On The Upper East Side

There are a lot of places to eat eggs and pancakes in the middle of the day on the Upper East Side. Here are our favorites.