NYCReview

John Brown Smokehouse review image

John Brown Smokehouse

$$$$

27-20 40th Ave, Long Island City
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

We've been meaning to hit up John Brown Smokehouse for a while, partially because people speak quite highly of the BBQ (see recent Village Voice award), but also because their bearded logo is pretty awesome. We have to say though, that while we enjoyed our time with John Brown, we didn't quite go crazy over the BBQ the way others have.

You know us. We're always down to tackle a full spread of assorted smoked meats, but nothing we ate here had us thinking best BBQ in NYC. Part of that may be because they were out of their best and most celebrated meat, the brisket burnt ends. We were there early too, at like 7pm, so we can only imagine that being out of the ends is a regular occurrence. We loved the lamb sausage and pulled pork, but the brisket definitely wasn't incredible, and the ribs and sides were kind of a bummer. We did, however, really like the overall vibe of this place. The Smokehouse recently re-located from a small Astoria space to a larger hub in Long Island City, complete with a big boy beer garden, a live music stage, picnic tables, and copious amounts of hangout space. It's gonna be a prime candidate for the Summer Guide 2K13. Unfortunately, they haven't updated their Google Maps location to LIC, yet and we were moments away from taking an incorrect train to the wrong spot. A word to the wise - make sure you know where you're going, and don't trust the map on your phone. If it's Apple Maps, you're probably f*cked either way.

At the end of the day, if you and your crew appreciate trays full of BBQ and massive bootfuls of beer, John Brown should be on the radar. Just temper expectations, and pray for burnt ends.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Food Rundown

John Brown Ruben

We loved this house cured pastrami - it had tons of flavor. It worked better on this sandwich though than it did independently, so definitely order up the ruben. It's tasty, but you might also be wishing for some more Russian dressing. There's a lot of meat there, and they go a little too easy on the fixins.

P.B.L.T.

This is a solid sandwich with pork belly, tomato, lettuce and mayo. You're best bet is gonna be to just load this thing up with BBQ sauce though. That sauce makes everything better.

John Brown Smokehouse review image

Pulled Pork

8 out of 10 - this is some excellent pulled pork. It's all kinds of moist, and has tons of flavor.

Pork Belly

4 out of 10 - maybe we got a bad cut or something, but our belly was ridiculously fatty (even for pork belly) and even the prime pieces just weren't as soft and tender as we would have hoped.

Rib Tips

9 out of 10 - flavor is the key at John Brown. Some dishes have lots of it, others don't. The tips have tons. Aside from the lamb sausage, this was our favorite meat of the night. Charred, thick, and meaty, these beef triangles must be on your tray.

Beef Brisket

6 out of 10 - a little dry and not that exciting. We ate it all, but we also didn't freak out over it.

Burnt Ends

10 out of 10? - Most likely, but we just don't know. Clearly, these are in high demand and since there are only so many brisket ends, but being that they routinely run out of their best dish is devastating. We came all the way from Manhattan (not really that far, but still) and wound up leaving without tasting John Brown's best dish.

Home Cured Pastrami

7 out of 10 - as we discussed above, it's delicious, but fares better on a sandwich than it does on its own.

Lamb Sausage

10 out of 10 - the lamb sausage is crazy delicious and crazy flavorful. This was the best thing we tasted at John Brown.

Pork Rubs

5 out of 10 - not much to see here. The ribs were average. They were a little dry, with little meat on the bones and they required tons of BBQ sauce..

John Brown Smokehouse review image

Sides

Generally unimpressive. Mac 'n cheese, cole slaw, collard greens...none of it was anything we'd want to eat twice. The fries were our favorite side, which doesn't say much.

John Brown Smokehouse review image

Beers

10 out of 10 - any restaurant that serves a glass boot full of sixty ounces of beer earns bonus points from Immaculate Infatuation.

Featured in

The Best BBQ In NYC guide image
Guide
The Best BBQ In NYC

From a pop-up serving chicharrón and smoked turkey to a place that offers plant-based takes on ribs and pulled pork, here's where to find the best Southern-style BBQ.

Where To Eat In Long Island City guide image
Guide
Where To Eat In Long Island City

All of the best spots to eat in Long Island City.

Where To Eat Outside In Long Island City guide image
Guide
Where To Eat Outside In Long Island City

11 spots to eat and drink outside in Long Island City.

Where To Eat & Drink When You’re Remembering How To Socialize guide image
Guide
Where To Eat & Drink When You’re Remembering How To Socialize

20 spots where you can be a social butterfly who has just emerged from the cocoon you call an apartment.

Suggested Reading

Fette Sau review image
Review
Fette Sau

Ladies and gentlemen, we have a new favorite BBQ spot. Situated inside what used to be an old auto body shop, this gutted garage is raging every night of the week.

Hill Country review image
Review
Hill Country

Hill Country serves Texas-style BBQ in a huge two-floor space in Flatiron.

Mighty Quinn’s Barbecue review image
Review
Mighty Quinn’s Barbecue

One of the best BBQ options in New York City, Might Quinn’s started at Smorgasburg and is becoming a smoked meat empire.

Sweet Spot review image
Review
Sweet Spot

Sweet Spot is a massive bar in Astoria with more than 40 TVs playing just about every sport you can imagine.