NYCReview

Mighty Quinn’s Barbecue review image

Mighty Quinn's Barbecue

$$$$

103 2nd Ave, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

Did someone say Brontosaurus Rib? On a menu in NYC? You now have our undivided attention. As we’re all well aware, barbecue isn’t a game we play on home ice here in New York (hockey reference?). It’s not native to this land, and try as we may, there are only a few smoked meats in this town that can hang with the good stuff south of the Mason Dixon line. Mighty Quinn’s is one of them.

Mighty Quinn’s got their start at Smorgasburg. A former drummer from Houston was smoking meat in Pennsylvania and driving it in to Brooklyn every weekend. Soon people started lining up for it. What started as a personal obsession for the pit master suddenly got the attention of people Brooklyn. Mighty Quinn’s would sell out of food every weekend, and quickly became the most popular vendor at Smorgasburg. Now, having fine tuned their craft as a pop-up, they have unleashed their Texas meets Carolina “Texalina” BBQ on the East Village. Get excited. Because Mighty Quinn’s first brick-and-mortar home is the real deal.

The reason you should be so excited is that the food at Mighty Quinn’s is most definitely not the “good by New York standards” kind of BBQ that you’ll find in so many other places. Mighty Quinn’s meats are so juicy and tender they sweat beautiful little fat droplets, and it’s so smoky and flavorful that no sauce is necessary. The sides are great, and the good selection of craft beer and simple design and layout of the restaurant make this place highly conducive to stress free, unrestrained BBQ smashing. There’s even a garage door ready to be lifted once the weather turns.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Food Rundown

Brisket

It’s a beautiful brisket. If you’re lucky, you’ll get some of the ends as that’s the best part. The moisture of the meat sings in perfect harmony with the simple, yet insanely flavorful salt, pepper, and paprika rub. Did I really just write that? Sorry, I’ve been reading too many Ruth Reichl Tweets. The bottom line is, this brisket is ridiculous. It’s better than Briskettown in Williamsburg, which we’ll be weighing in on soon.

Pulled Pork

Possibly the best thing on the menu, and that’s saying a lot. Again, it’s the perfect storm of meat flavor, meat texture, and meat love, which make Mighty Quinn’s meats a pleasure to eat. The dark, thick bark at the top is the best part. Make sure that crispy layer mixes in with the softer pork to get an awesome texture contrast.

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Everything that’s great about the pulled pork, but on a soft brioche bun. You win.

Brontosaurus Rib

Beef ribs in New York generally suck. They usually have too much rub on them, and require an awful amount of much work for an unsatisfying amount of meat. Not at Mighty Quinn’s. There is no question in my mind that this is the single best beef rib that’s ever crossed the George Washington Bridge. It’s literally a monster short rib, with fatty, mouth watering meat falling off the bone, begging to chomped on like a hyena on a zebra. Get your Fred Flintstone on and drop $23 on one of these suckers. You won’t regret it.

Spare Ribs

You know a rib is good when it doesn’t need any sauce. This is one of those rare pork ribs. Not as good as the beef rib, but good enough to go back for seconds.

Pickled Red Onions, Cucumbers, Chiles

We love all things pickled, so clearly we loved this. Bonus points for how nice the colors look on our Instagram. Did I say Ruth Reichl? Just kidding. I’m turning into Ina Garten.

Burnt End Baked Beans

These are incredible. Order some.

Edamame & Sweet Pea Salad

A different and refreshing way to get some greens in the mix. Maybe you’ll only have to run five miles tomorrow instead of six.

Slaw

Very solid. Not too much mayo and lots of vinegar. Just the way we like it.

Featured in

The NYC BBQ Delivery Guide guide image
Guide
The NYC BBQ Delivery Guide

When you’re in the mood for BBQ, these 11 spots have you covered.

The Best Places To Have Dinner For Around $30 In The East Village  guide image
Guide
The Best Places To Have Dinner For Around $30 In The East Village

The best dinners that $30 will buy you in the East Village.

Suggested Reading

Fette Sau review image
Review
Fette Sau

Ladies and gentlemen, we have a new favorite BBQ spot. Situated inside what used to be an old auto body shop, this gutted garage is raging every night of the week.

Hometown Bar-B-Que review image
Review
Hometown Bar-B-Que

Welcome to the Texas-style dining hall of sacred smoked meats known as Hometown Bar-B-Que.

John Brown Smokehouse review image
Review
John Brown Smokehouse

While we enjoyed our time with John Brown Smokehouse, we didn’t quite go crazy over the BBQ the way others have. Though if you and your crew appreciate trays full of BBQ and massive bootfuls of beer, John Brown should be on the radar.

Morgan's BBQ review image
Review
Morgan's BBQ

Morgan’s BBQ is some of the best barbecue you can get without having to go down to Red Hook for Hometown.