NYCReview

photo credit: Lizzie Munro

Gage and Tollner review image

Gage and Tollner

If Gage & Tollner in Downtown Brooklyn feels like a relic of old New York, that’s because it is. The restaurant opened in ​​1892, became a TGI Friday's in 2004, then reopened in 2020. The atmosphere is what makes the place—the dining room is full of floor-to-ceiling mirrors, there’s a revolving door from the original construction, and the bar up front is the perfect place to have a solo martini and some snacks.

Unless you have some wealthy relatives in town, Gage & Tollner is a place where you should stick with cocktails and snacks. The larger entrees, like a steak that would benefit from some finishing salt and a pot pie whose pastry can’t hold up to the soupy filling, tend to lack finesse. But a round of clams casino with kimchi butter or a plate of devils on horseback will enhance any high-end date night or outing with a friend.

Featured in

.
Restaurants Where You Should Read The Dessert Menu First guide image
Guide
Restaurants Where You Should Read The Dessert Menu First

These spots make our favorite desserts in NYC, so we recommend considering the sweet stuff first.

The Toughest Reservations In NYC Right Now (And How To Get Them) guide image
Guide
The Toughest Reservations In NYC Right Now (And How To Get Them)

Our thoughts on the busiest restaurants in New York City and advice on how to get in.

Where To Dress Up And Not Feel Stupid guide image
Guide
Where To Dress Up And Not Feel Stupid

If you're looking for a place to wear that sample sale piece sitting in the back of your closet, try one of these restaurants.

Suggested Reading

.
Union Square Cafe review image
Review
Union Square Cafe

Union Square Cafe is a classic New York City restaurant having its second life in a new space. The good news? It’s still as good as ever.

Ci Siamo review image
8.5
Review
Ci Siamo

Ci Siamo is an upscale Italian restaurant in Manhattan West with standout starters and pastas.

Misi review image
8.5
Review
Misi

Misi is the pasta-focused restaurant from the people behind one of our all-time favorite Brooklyn restaurants, Lilia.

The Nuaa Table review image
Review
The Nuaa Table

The Nuaa Table is a Thai spot in Prospect Heights where you should go to eat Jasmine tea-smoked ribs on their turf-covered outdoor patio.