NYCReview

photo credit: David A. Lee

Montauket review image

Montauket

$$$$
Perfect For:Live Music

A local classic since the ‘20s, Montauket is one of those Montauk spots where you can sip local beer, take in the sunset, and enjoy some live music, all while looking out at the bay. The menu is relatively simple with lobster rolls, caesar salads, and burgers, but that’s exactly why you come to a place like this— classics eaten on picnic tables, great water views, and plenty of drinks.

David A. Lee

Montauket review image

Featured in

.
The Best Restaurants In Montauk guide image
Guide
The Best Restaurants In Montauk

These are the 21 best places to eat and stay in Montauk.

Suggested Reading

.
Roberta's Montauk review image
Review
Roberta's Montauk

Roberta's, the Brooklyn favorite known for its wood-fired pizzas, has a new year-round outpost in the space that used to be Arbor.

Il Buco al Mar review image
Review
Il Buco al Mar

Il Buco al Mar is perfect for a dinner in Amagansett that's not too fussy but still a bit upscale.

John's Surf Shack review image
Review
John's Surf Shack

John's Surf Shack is a great place for fried seafood in Westhampton.

Joni's review image
Review
Joni's

Joni's should be your go-to breakfast spot in Montauk.