If you’re looking for a slice on the Upper West Side, you have some options. Mama’s Too is the best one - but what if you’re about 25 blocks south of there? Go to Made In New York. Sure, it has a redundant name, but the square pepperoni slice with its crispy cups and crunchy crust is excellent. The square white slice is also very good, as is the upside down one covered in an especially sweet tomato sauce. There are also a bunch of tables if you’d like to eat your slice immediately after purchasing it - but we usually just take ours to go.
Home Cities
Pick the perfect spot for every situation
- Atlanta
- Austin
- Boston
- Chicago
- London
- Los Angeles
- Miami
- New York
- Philadelphia
- San Francisco
- Seattle
- Washington DC
Travel Guides
Plan your trip and eat like locals
- All Travel Guides
- Barcelona
- Berlin
- Cape Town
- Charleston
- Dallas
- Detroit
- Denver
- Hong Kong
- Houston
- Hudson Valley
- Joshua Tree
- Las Vegas
- Madrid
- Maui
- Melbourne
- Mexico City
- Minneapolis
- Montreal
- Nashville
- New Orleans
- North Carolina
- Orlando
- Palm Springs
- Paris
- Phoenix
- Pittsburgh
- Portland, ME
- Portland, OR
- Rome
- San Diego
- Santa Barbara
- Singapore
- St. Louis
- Sydney
- Tokyo
- Toronto
- Vancouver
- Cocktails
Don’t see your city? Drop us a line and let us know where you’d like us to go next.
Thank You
We’re always looking to make The Infatuation the best platform to find restaurants, and we appreciate your feedback!
Hi Infatuation reader. With restaurants around the country reopening, we understand that socializing in any form might still feel strange, and poses risks too. Should you go out to eat? That’s up to you. But we’ll continue to keep you informed as best we can. If you have any questions or concerns, feel free to email us at community@theinfatuation.com.
