NYCReview

photo credit: Emily Schindler

Jeffrey’s Grocery review image

Jeffrey’s Grocery

$$$$

172 Waverly Pl, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

We’re constantly on the move trying new places, because if we didn’t, this site would get stale and you would be forced to read... actually let’s not think about that. But even though we have to cover a lot of ground, there are a few spots we return to often because they are Perfect For so many things. Jeffrey’s Grocery is the ideal example of that. This is one of the few restaurants in this city where we’re legitimate regulars.

When Jeffrey’s Grocery first opened, it was a kitschy little cafe that also tried peddling groceries. Realizing that there was absolutely no need to sell milk and eggs to people who were just looking to go face deep into some raw bar, the restaurant went through a makeover for the best. They ditched the faux store-front, upgraded the chef, and made the most out of the space.

Even though we’re here so often, we hadn’t updated our review since all these changes for the better were made. So here we are to tell you that this place is still awesome. We love Jeffrey’s because the people are friendly, it’s easy to get in, and the food is great - especially the raw bar and the incredible clam chowder. It’s our go-to West Village weekday lunch move, and one of the better brunch situations in town because you generally won’t have to wait. It’s also just a fun place to hang out, and that’s important in our book.

More important than groceries.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Food Rundown

Jeffrey’s Grocery review image

Raw Bar

Oysters and king crab legs - that’s the one-two punch we go with at Jeffrey’s. That said, you really can’t go wrong with anything from the raw bar. Order freely.

Crab Biscuit Benedict

Poached eggs on a biscuit with crab meat, lobster hollandaise sauce, potatoes, and greens. This is our favorite thing from the brunch menu, and you’re gonna want it.

Pancakes

Lemon ricotta flapjacks with blueberry compote. A no-brainer.

The Fresser Platter For Two

This one is a big bagel party on a wooden board, with gravlax, smoked salmon, latkes, whitefish salad, scrambled eggs, etc. All the things you need to live well.

Jeffrey’s Grocery review image

Clam Chowder

Not too thick, not too thin, with full littleneck clams and just the right amount of cream. This is one of our favorite chowders in town. Bacon bits only make it better.

Spinach Salad

A straightforward, very tasty salad of healthy greens, toasted pumpkin seeds, apple, and smoked cheddar in a cider vinaigrette. We eat this on every visit.

Braised Brisket Sandwich

This sandwich is legendary and has been on the menu since the beginning. Moist chunks of brisket with red beet-horseradish slaw and muenster cheese oozing out of warm, toasted sourdough. It’s more manicured than the typical massive New York deli-style brisket sandwiches, and we appreciate that.

Jeffrey’s Grocery review image

Crispy Salmon

This salmon filet comes in a corn broth with shrimp and a ton of vegetables. Order it.

Fish ’N Chips

The fish ’n chips here is excellent, and it comes with donut holes and a malt maple vinegar dipping sauce. So really, it’s fish ’n chips ’n donuts ’n maple.

Featured in

The Best Brunch In The West Village guide image
Guide
The Best Brunch In The West Village

Where to go when you want to eat anything from banana pancakes to monkfish and eggs on a day that starts with the letter S.

The Best Lobster Rolls In NYC guide image
Guide
The Best Lobster Rolls In NYC

Where to get a lobster roll that's actually worth the money.

The Best Oyster Happy Hours In NYC guide image
Guide
The Best Oyster Happy Hours In NYC

Our favorite spots for discounted shellfish.

Great Restaurants For A Last-Minute Date Night guide image
Guide
Great Restaurants For A Last-Minute Date Night

Spontaneous date night? We have you covered.

Suggested Reading

Joseph Leonard review image
Review
Joseph Leonard

Conceived in the spirit of Little Owl, this is a tiny West Village restaurant perfectly engineered for surveying action while you eat. Dinner is generally better than brunch, but it's a nice place to dine any time of day.

Little Owl review image
Review
Little Owl

A love letter to Little Owl, sort of.

Sel Rrose review image
Review
Sel Rrose

A cocktail bar that specializes in oysters, and has a very solid burger. Sel Rrose isn't our favorite oyster hangout, but it's definitely one you should know about.

Fedora review image
Review
Fedora

Fedora is in the basement of a townhouse in the West Village, and it feels like a dinner party in a speakeasy that your friends happen to own.