NYCReview

photo credit: Teddy Wolff

Crown Shy review image
7.4

Crown Shy

$$$$

70 Pine St, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

We have feelings about the future of New American food, revolving primarily around the fact that almost none of it feels new. Instead, the phrase has become synonymous with extravagant dining rooms, too-cool-for-school service, and mains for two that cost more than $100. This is exactly what you’ll get at Crown Shy, a Tribeca spot that was once extremely happening, but is now the kind of place you take your parents when they’re visiting in the middle of the week.

The food at Crown Shy is not bad. We still find their grilled chicken, olive bread, gruyere fritters, and ice cream sundaes enjoyable enough. But Crown Shy presents itself as a restaurant that’s drawing from global influences, embracing seasonality, and generally trying to be creative. Ultimately, we don’t see those qualities on the plate, and that’s kind of a bummer. Best case scenario, you'll eat very standard "seasonal" American fare that isn’t tied to any particular season: chicken, bread, cheese, and ice cream. 

There was a time when we’d have said you should absolutely go out of your way to eat at Crown Shy. Now, we think of it more as a utility spot. You’re in or near Tribeca, and you need to eat somewhere with a bit of polish and reliable-if-uninspiring food. In that situation, Crown Shy is a perfectly good choice. But it’s no longer the best. 

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Food Rundown

Crown Shy review image

Olive Bread

Pretty much everyone likes the olive bread at Crown Shy. It’s the first thing to hit your table, and it reminds us of Pillsbury crescent rolls slathered with olive tapenade and served with some nicely-salted labneh. Just be sure to eat it while it’s hot, because, like Pillsbury crescent rolls, it’s significantly less delicious at room temp.

Crown Shy review image

Gruyere Fritters

If you come here, you should order these. As with the bread, eat them while they’re hot, when the cheese inside these bite-sized churros still tastes like Gruyere. Once cooled, it takes on the distinctive flavor of Cheez Wiz. Again, not bad, but not as good.

Crown Shy review image

White Bean Hummus

Another reliable starter. Sometimes it’s served with puffy bread, sometimes it’s served with crisp veggies. We like the vegetable edition better, since it cuts the richness of the ‘nduja.

Crown Shy review image

Grilled Chicken

The dish that initially made people excited about Crown Shy is still a very good piece of chicken. It’s juicy, the outside has a pleasant, smoky char, and the hot sauce foam has a buzzy but not overwhelming amount of heat. The best main on the menu.

Crown Shy review image

Desserts

For the most part, we really like the desserts at Crown Shy, especially the sticky toffee pudding with apple sorbet. It tastes like school and autumn and being cozy, no matter what time of year it is. Their ice creams overall are very good, though the toppings are sometimes too sweet to balance out the equation.

Bucatini

A totally fine pasta dish that’s nothing special, even when served with in-season morel mushrooms. That about sums it up.

Featured in

New York City’s Best New Restaurants Of 2019 guide image

New York City’s Best New Restaurants Of 2019

The Infatuation’s Favorite New Restaurants Of 2019 guide image

The Infatuation’s Favorite New Restaurants Of 2019

Where To Get a Sidecar Cocktail In NYC guide image

Where To Get a Sidecar Cocktail In NYC

20 Restaurants Open For Indoor Dining Today guide image

20 Restaurants Open For Indoor Dining Today

Suggested Reading

Benno review image
Review
Benno

Benno serves prix-fixe menus of French and Italian food in the Evelyn Hotel in Nomad.

Chef’s Table At Brooklyn Fare review image
Review
Chef’s Table At Brooklyn Fare

Chef’s Table At Brooklyn Fare in Hell’s Kitchen serves a tasting menu that’s unlike anything else you’ll eat in NYC.

Francie review image
8.6
Review
Francie

Francie is a fancy Williamsburg brasserie where you should grab dinner for a big night out.

Infatuation Logo
2023 © The Infatuation Inc. All Rights Reserved.

FIND PLACES ON OUR APP

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store