Paulie Gee's Slice Shop
Paulie Gee's Slice Shop is the grab-and-go sibling of the original Paulie Gee's, and it's possible we like this location the best. The pizza is excellent, from the basic cheese slice to their signature Hellboy, which started the Mike's Hot Honey on pizza trend. They also make solid vegan pizza in both square and round formats. Importantly, you can get L&B Spumoni Gardens ices and spumoni here without making the journey to Gravesend. There's also a small area where you can hang out and drink wine or beer while you eat your pizza if you're not using this as a place to get a high-end walking slice.
photo credit: Nitzan Rubin