NY Pizza Suprema

NY Pizza Suprema has been around since before the city erected MSG in front of it. They serve about 20 varieties of pizza at any given time, including breaded chicken bacon ranch slices, a few vegan options, and a white spinach dip slice that’s just creamy enough without being over-the-top. The upside-down grandma slice is our absolute favorite. It makes the best use of Suprema’s extra-puffy crust, which can easily hold the generous helping of sweet tomato sauce. There’s always a line, but if you aren’t coming directly after an event at MSG, you’ll move through it pretty quickly.