Order one slice at this small counter-service spot on 181st Street if you’re hungry, and two if a self-help podcast convinced you to enjoy the present. Even the margherita - our favorite - has enough mozzarella and dense, doughy crust to function as a last meal for a bear heading into hibernation. But no matter what, make sure to get a side of garlic bread, which is charred and crispy, painted with butter, and topped with a ton of black pepper. Whether or not you order it with cheese is between you and your future self.
Where we've featured it
More spots in Washington HeightsSee more
El Panadero Bakery
El Panadero Bakery in Washington Heights is a great stop for breakfast and something sweet.
Elsa La Reina del Chicharron
Elsa La Reina Del Chicharron is a neighborhood Dominican spot where you can eat your weight in very good chicharron.
Buunni Coffee is a great place to grab coffee (and an injera wrap) in Washington Heights.
More Italian spotsSee more
Dough Vale is a small, sit-down pizza spot in Williamsburg that’s a good option for a casual date.
Pasta Dal Cuore
Pasta Dal Cuore is a BYOB Italian spot in Jersey City that serves some very good housemade pastas.
San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina
If you want to sit down and eat a good pizza on the UES, San Matteo is the place. It’s big and casual, and there’s also stuff besides pizza here.
Suggested by our writers
Mama’s Too is a tiny pizza place on the Upper West Side, and it’s where you’ll find some of the best slices in the area. Get the square pepperoni one.
PQR is a Roman-style pizza spot on the Upper East Side serving slices topped with everything from pumpkin to porchetta.
El Floridita Restaurant
Floridita is a Cuban spot in Washington Heights that serves one of the best Cubano sandwiches in the city.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more