Since August, Pizza Yard on Governors Island has been working out of a shed equipped with a wood-burning oven, and the result is some of the best pizza in the whole city. The bubbly crust has a nice crunch and the sauce tastes like the sweet yet acidic grand prize winner at a tomato sauce festival (which is unfortunately not a thing in NYC). You should absolutely make a day out of gazing at the Statue of Liberty and writing a poem for this pizza.
Where we've featured it
Search by Perfect For
More spots in Governors IslandSee more
More Pizza spotsSee more
The self-proclaimed "first pizzeria in America," Lombardi's has long been at the top of the list for tourists looking for a taste of real NYC pizza.
Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop
An order-at-the-counter slice place from the people beind one of our all-time favorite pizza spots, Paulie Gee’s.
We feel sorry for anyone who doesn’t have a Paulie Gee’s in their neighborhood as an option for excellent Neapolitan pies.
Suggested by our writers
Lucali is a walk-in-only spot in Carroll Gardens that serves the best pizza in New York City.
Roberta’s is the most important pizza joint in New York City, and this commune of Brooklyn culture only gets better with age.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more