NYCReview

Lost Borough Ice Cream review image

Lost Borough Ice Cream

$$$$(914) 810-4604
Hours:THU
12PM-8PM

This little scoop shop in Yonkers is on par with the biggest players in the NYC ice cream scene. The menu is extensive, with everything from regional favorites like Grape Nut (IYKYK) to a lemon blueberry cake flavor we haven’t been able to stop thinking about. They also make really great homemade banana pudding, if for some reason you don’t want your dessert frozen.

Featured in

.
The Best Ice Cream In NYC guide image
Guide
The Best Ice Cream In NYC

For a scoop of something cold, here’s where to go.

Suggested Reading

.
The Best Ice Cream In NYC guide image
Guide
The Best Ice Cream In NYC

For a scoop of something cold, here’s where to go.

Surreal Creamery review image
Review
Surreal Creamery

This Greenwich Village spot has sundaes in mason jars, but the “floateas” (soft serve on top of bubble tea) are why you come here.

Ample Hills Creamery review image
Review
Ample Hills Creamery

Ample Hills is a truly excellent ice cream shop, especially if you're not a purist when it comes to your flavors.

Eddie’s Sweet Shop review image
Review
Eddie’s Sweet Shop

Eddie’s is an old-school ice cream parlor in Forest Hills where you can eat a giant sundae and feel like a kid.