NYCReview

Island Shack review image

Island Shack

$$$$

87 South Elliott Pl, Brooklyn
Earn 3X Points

This casual Caribbean restaurant in Fort Green serves jerk chicken that we can’t currently remove from our dreams. Whether you get this chicken in wing form or as an entree, it’ll be covered in a smoky dry rub and doused with sticky, spicy sauce. Island Shack’s menu shows a range of influence, with everything from Jamaican oxtails and rice and peas to Trini-style roti and curry goat. Although the restaurant is currently waiting on their liquor license, it’s already a high-energy place to meet a date or a couple friends for a group dinner (and the scene will probably get even rowdier with rum cocktails in the mix). 

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Featured in

Where To Eat Before A Show At Brooklyn Academy Of Music  guide image
Guide
Where To Eat Before A Show At Brooklyn Academy Of Music

Where to grab a meal before that new wave production of Hamlet.

The Brooklyn Hit List: The Best New Restaurants In Brooklyn guide image
Guide
The Brooklyn Hit List: The Best New Restaurants In Brooklyn

A natural wine bar in Clinton Hill, a Persian spot serving potato tahdig in Bushwick, and more new restaurants to check out.

The Best Restaurants For Affordable Group Dinners guide image
Guide
The Best Restaurants For Affordable Group Dinners

Where to get dinner with a group when you want the food to be more memorable than the bill.

Where To Eat With A Third-Tier Friend guide image
Guide
Where To Eat With A Third-Tier Friend

When you somehow rope yourself into dinner with a friend you don’t see too often, use this list.