New York Grilled Cheese Co. review image

New York Grilled Cheese Co.


2207 Wilton Dr, Wilton Manors
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

When Broward folks crave a grilled cheese sandwich, all roads lead to New York Grilled Cheese. This sandwich shop is right in the middle of Wilton’s most popular nightlife (and it’s open late on weekends), so this is the neighborhood’s best late-night drunk food. What makes the grilled cheese here unique is that they’re pressed on waffle irons, which increases the crispy surface area of each sandwich. But the fillings are what really bring people in like cheesy, melty sirens calling out to Odysseus. Our favorite sandwich is the Fifth Avenue, filled with boneless panko-crusted fried chicken tossed in a sweet Sriracha sauce and pressed with bacon, American cheese, and muenster. New York Grilled Cheese also serves waffle fries, including ones made into poutine and a sweet potato version with marshmallow dipping sauce.

New York Grilled Cheese Co. review image

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.

By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Featured in

The Best Restaurants In Wilton Manors guide image
The Best Restaurants In Wilton Manors

Our favorite places to eat in Wilton Manors, South Florida's most LGBTQ-friendly city.

Suggested Reading

J28 Sandwich Bar review image
J28 Sandwich Bar

J28 Sandwich Bar in Hollywood, Florida makes the best Peruvian sandwiches and empanadas in South Florida.

Papa Duke's Deli review image
Papa Duke's Deli

Papa Duke's Deli is a New England-style sandwich shop in Wilton Manors that makes a good Italian sub.

Sub Center review image
Sub Center

Sub Center in Hollywood, Florida is an old-school independent sub shop where you can customize your sandwiches with dozens of condiments.

The Best Sandwiches In Miami  guide image
The Best Sandwiches In Miami

Miami is a sandwich city, and here is our starting lineup.

Infatuation Logo
2023 © The Infatuation Inc. All Rights Reserved.


Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store