Ecco un Poco
If you're the indecisive type, Ecco un Poco on W. 3rd Street is easy to navigate: there are only a dozen flavors at any given time. And even though you can't choose from seven different single-origin chocolate varieties, the flavors you can sample are nothing short of excellent. There are a few signatures that never get cycled out, including one with toasted Piedmont hazelnuts that are, according to EU Law, the black truffle of nuts. If you want something sweeter and stretchy like taffy, get the honey custard that's luscious from egg yolks and caramelized honey. And if gelato runs here turn into a habit, be aware that there's a rewards program.