There are some things New Jersey does as well as anywhere in the country: be the set of HBO shows, house the stadiums of other states’ sports teams, and serve great Italian food. Combine that (just the bit about the Italian food) with the fact that LBI has great seafood, and you get some of the best food on the island at Stefano’s. This upscale spot in Beach Haven does straightforward Italian dishes really well, like eggplant parm and housemade meatballs, as well as some seafood, like crab-encrusted salmon over lobster mashed potatoes. But our favorite things here are the combinations, like local scallops over crab and tomato risotto, and penne vodka with shrimp, scallops, and lots of crab meat. Bring some Chianti or barbera (it’s BYOB), and try to get a table on the outdoor patio if it’s nice out.
Where we've featured it
More spots in Long Beach IslandSee more
Holiday Snack Bar
Holiday Snack Bar is a Beach Haven spot that feels like it was transported here from the ’50s.
Yellowfin is an upscale seafood spot on Long Beach Island that’s a good option for date night.
Viking Fresh Off The Hook
Viking Fresh Off The Hook is a counter-service spot in Barnegat Light with great fried seafood.
More Italian spotsSee more
La Locanda Del Ghiottone
La Locada del Ghittone is an Italian BYOB in Old City that serves super solid and affordable pasta.
If you’re going to a show at Union Transfer, stop by Osteria before hand to eat some pasta outside.
Suggested by our writers
Blue Water Cafe
Blue Water Cafe is a BYOB spot on Long Beach Island with good seafood and a fantastic burger topped with blue crab dip.
Whether you want a big selection of craft beers, great chicken wings, or $1 oysters, The Arlington is one of your best options on Long Beach Island.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more