Anthony’s Seafood Market and Restaurant

Anthony’s in Middletown serves some of the island’s best seafood, and you’ll most likely always encounter a line. Place your order, and then make your way over to the first-come, first-serve picnic tables and enjoy the bustling fishmarket-meets-beachfront lobster bar. All the fish is fresh and delicious, whether you’re in the mood for lobster, scallops, and steamers. There are a few solid kid- and land-lover-friendly options on the menu, too, but you're really here for some classic New England seafood.