Maroni

Maroni isn't your average Long Island Italian spot. Their a la carte menu includes a bunch of things you wouldn't expect, like Korean-style ribs and chicken and ginger dumplings, and it all just sort of works. Skip their tasting menu, which they offer most nights, and instead, share a few small plates of gagootz parmesan and a penne alla vodka with a sauce so smooth, you wouldn’t mind it as a savory milkshake. If you can, claim a spot in the front window that overlooks Main Street.