Ice Cream Cafe has dozens of interesting flavors, like avocado and brownie batter, and many vegan, non-dairy, sugar-free, and gluten-free options. If you come here in the late afternoon or early evening, there’s usually a line out the door that spills onto the deck, but it moves quickly. When you want something more classic, try flavors like black raspberry, peppermint stick, orange sherbet, and maple walnut, and add on a salt-water taffy if you feel like some dessert after your dessert.