Danny Meyer. Gobbling up screen time on this site just like he’s gobbling up restaurant space all over town. We finally got around to a review of The Modern, and it’s about time, they needed more good press. Or wait a minute, no they didn’t. Along with a Michelin Star and constant raves, Chef Gabriel Kreuther was honored recently with a James Beard award for Best Chef: NYC. We’re actually still waiting to find out if we won for Most Influential Food Website: Earth. They’ll call or something right?
The best way for us to give you the lowdown on this place is to explain that it’s really two different experiences: the bar, and the dining room. The dining room is a beautiful, formal space overlooking the MoMa garden with a three course prixe fixe menu. It’s fine dining for sure, and it’s incredibly good. Think of it as a more “modern” Eleven Madison Park. The bar area is quite a bit different. It’s sleek, more relaxed, and on a good night, you’ll find some Action at the Bar. The plates are smaller and a bit more restrained, but you will still get A plus service and have a decent meal. We like the bar just fine, but what it really comes down to is this: That James Beard award didn’t get handed over for restraint and small plates. Chef Kruether is rocking a new neck accessory because of what’s happening in the dining room. So if you’re looking for a place to take grandma to dinner after you freak her out at the Tim Burton exhibit, bump this rating up a full point. It’s a top notch restaurant, but the bar can be a bit hit-or-miss, and if we’re doing it fancy, Eleven Madison park is more our speed.
The bar version of this with some radish and yuzu is fine, but what you want is the tartare in the dining room that comes served with a thin slice of watermelon. That’s where it’s at.
Upside Down Tuna Tarte
A tuna tartare, but with a thin, crunchy pastry sitting on top. Pretty tasty.
A nice, delicate pasta, though I expected this to have more flavor than it did. It’s fine, but it’s also an example of why you’re better off spending your money in the dining room.
Homemade Alsatian Country Sausage
Probably the best thing on the bar menu, this is an incredibly satisfying home made sausage. DBGB, take note.
Dry Aged Strip Loin
Sliced thin and served over spaetzele, this is an awesome bar menu option.
Long Island Duck Breast
We had some west coast duck at Eleven Madison Park a while back, and it was mind blowing. There is usually some duck on both menus at The Modern, and you should be eating it.
Red Beet Risotto
Ok. There is gold leaf in this dish, which is something you’ll see on a plate every once in a while in The Modern dining room. I would normally take this opportunity to make some sarcastic Goldschlager reference, but will skip it this time – just because this risotto is so good.
Loup de Mer
A really nice, light filet of Loup de Mer, a white fish. This will come with various things on the plate, depending on the season. I think ours had some mushroom action, and maybe a clam.
You Might Also Like
Fancy though it may be, Eleven Madison Park is surprisingly lively. But make no mistake, this is fine dining at its most serious.
A year after our initial review, we check back in on Betony, already one of our favorite fine dining destinations in New York City. We'd rather do our fine dining here than almost anywhere downtown. Or uptown for that matter.
Marea is one of those restaurants, like Eleven Madison Park, you walk into knowing damn well it’s going to be incredible. It’s also good to know this: Marea is a Quality Fish restaurant first, Italian restaurant second.
A Voce is definitely Italian fine dining, it will definitely hit you hard in the wallet, and it's definitely full of suits from the New York Life building next door, but no matter - the food coming out of this kitchen is amazing.
Annisa isn’t your typical Infatuation-style restaurant. It’s a little stuffy. Fortunately, these standard deal-breakers become mere observations once the kitchen starts putting incredible food on your table.