SEAReview

Windy City Pie review image
8.6

Windy City Pie

Updated November 22nd, 2021

Windy City Pie started out as an undercover operation. To get one of their deep dish pizzas, you had to call in your order, drive to some random SoDo parking lot, text the owner when you arrived, and meet him outside to discreetly exchange your cold hard cash for a hot, Chicago-style pie. After relocating to the Batch 206 Distillery as a pop-up, they still didn’t have a full-blown restaurant, but this time there were appetizers, and you didn’t feel like someone could be hiding in the bushes recording clandestine surveillance footage of you.

In both the parking lot and the pop-up, the only problem was that the pies took 45 minutes to bake. It’s nobody’s fault - you can’t rush the process of making f*cking phenomenal, puffy deep dish wrapped in a near-burnt, caramelized-cheese crust. But at Windy City Pie’s location in Phinney Ridge, they’ve taken care of the long-wait dilemma, making their already outstanding pizza somehow even better.

Even if you’re dining in, you’re required to preorder exactly when your pizza will be ready. Simply go on their website, select a time (whether it’s 8:30pm next Friday or two hours from now), and you’ll get your food as soon as you sit down. There’s something remarkable about showing up, being presented to your table like some kind of pizza VIP, and immediately getting a pie fresh out of the oven. It’s like having a fairy godmother, only instead of a nice old lady with wings who magically gifts you a horse-drawn carriage, it’s an internet submission form that makes deep dish instantly appear whenever you walk into Windy City Pie. It’s clear they’ve thought of everything - the servers will even teach you how to slice your pizza and reheat your leftovers, oven temperature, timing, and all. With this preordering system, we’re never going back to waiting around an hour for a pizza. And neither should you.

Nate Watters

Windy City Pie review image

We did the math - there are nearly 90,000 different ways you can top a pizza at Windy City Pie. Whatever you’re putting on your pizza, stick with the red-sauced pies over the white ones. You could theoretically order a plain cheese pie, but they recommend you start with one of their signatures. Like the “Meatza,” which is topped with housemade sausage, pepperoni, and crunchy candied bacon. Make sure to get a vegetable dish too, like the incredible kale caesar, and a side of tangy pickled giardiniera - they cut through the heaviness of the pizza.

Inside, there aren’t any Cubs or Bears banners slapping you across the face, and there’s no poster of the Portillo’s logo. Instead, there’s an assortment of vintage Chicago World’s Fair posters and neighborhood maps hung up around the restaurant. Not every tap pours midwestern beer, but they casually serve Jeppson’s Malört, a horrible liquor that Chicagoans love. Whether you’re a diehard Pequod’s fan or somebody that just likes pizza, getting the best deep dish in Seattle has never been easier.

The Infatuation in your inbox.

Be the first to get our newest guides & reviews, plus exclusive restaurant intel.

Food Rundown

All Kale Caesar

This caesar is the best possible thing you can eat with your heavy, doughy pizza. It’s delicious - there’s lots of green leaves, a tangy vinaigrette dressing, a blizzard of grated parmesan, and a wedge of lemon for squeezing over the top.

Meatza

If you went to Windy City Pie and never ordered anything other than the “Meatza,” you wouldn’t be missing out. The combination of sausage, pepperoni, and sweet candied bacon isn’t too heavy, and the crispy-crusted edges of the pie are the best part.

Windy City Pie review image

Brussels Snout

The red-sauced pies beat the white ones any day, but if you’re ordering two and want to eat vegetables, the “Brussels Snout” is a terrific way to go. It has candied bacon, caramelized onions, and brussels sprouts for health.

Windy City Pie review image

Giardiniera

This medley of chopped peppers, cauliflower, carrots, and olives adds a briny and spicy crunch to your pie. You can also get it in a little dish on the side, which we highly recommend.

Featured in

.
Seattle’s Delivery & Takeout Options For Every Situation guide image
Guide
Seattle’s Delivery & Takeout Options For Every Situation

Want to have a big night in? Desperately need to stock your pantry? Here are some takeout options to make social distancing suck less.

Seattle Restaurants With New Takeout & Delivery Options guide image
Guide
Seattle Restaurants With New Takeout & Delivery Options

Find something great to eat for dinner at home, and support Seattle restaurants while you’re at it.

The Seattle Alcohol Delivery & Pick-Up Guide guide image
Guide
The Seattle Alcohol Delivery & Pick-Up Guide

All the bars, restaurants, wine shops, and breweries that’ll help keep your bar cart full while you’re stuck at home.

The Best Salads In Seattle guide image
Guide
The Best Salads In Seattle

Where to eat plates of lettuce that taste good.

Suggested Reading

.
Breezy Town Pizza review image
Review
Breezy Town Pizza

Breezy Town Pizza is a Chicago-style pizzeria operating from inside Clock-Out Lounge in Beacon Hill.

Dino’s Tomato Pie review image
Review
Dino’s Tomato Pie

Dino’s is one of few places in Seattle that knows how to do Grandma-style pizza. It’s one of our favorite spots on Capitol Hill for dinner and drinks.

Supreme review image
Review
Supreme

Supreme is a West Seattle pizzeria with New York-style pies and slices, plus boozy slushies and excellent garlic knots.

Supreme Pizza review image
Review
Supreme Pizza

Supreme is a great New York-style pizzeria in the University District. Get the garlic knots.