To successfully acquire pizza from West Of Chicago, you have to order and pay for it online, roll up to a random door on the side of a building, text a phone number, and wait for someone to come out with your order. It’s kind of like buying an elliptical machine from somebody on Craigslist - it’s not worth the awkwardness that comes with getting it. The crust is made of cornmeal, which reminds us more of lemon meringue pie crust than pizza crust, the toppings are forgettable, and the sauce isn’t much of a sauce at all - it’s more like briefly cooked diced tomatoes with a lot of sweetness. We’re not running around telling our friends about it. Our advice: get your Chicago-style at Windy City Pie instead.
Search by Perfect For
More spots in West SeattleSee more
Il Nido is an upscale Italian restaurant in West Seattle that specializes in homemade pasta and isn’t worth the hype.
New Luck Toy
New Luck Toy is a great bar in West Seattle with skee-ball, karaoke, tiki drinks, an explosion of decorations, and incredible Chinese food.
More Pizza spotsSee more
Cinque Terre is an Italian restaurant in South Lake Union that serves pasta and excellent Neapolitan pizza.
Big Mario’s Pizza
Big Mario’s is a very respectable NY-style slice joint in Cap Hill during the day, and a late night eats mecca at night.
Suggested by our writers
Supreme is a West Seattle pizzeria with New York-style pies and slices, plus boozy slushies and excellent garlic knots.
Dino’s Tomato Pie
Dino’s is one of few places in Seattle that knows how to do New York pizza. It’s one of our favorite spots in Cap Hill for dinner and drinks.
Breezy Town Pizza
Breezy Town Pizza is a Chicago-style pizzeria operating from inside Clock-Out Lounge in Beacon Hill.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more