The Admiral Benbow Room
The Admiral Benbow Room is the closest thing you'll get to drinking rum on a pirate ship. With a dark space covered in barrels, projectors playing murky underwater b-roll, and a giant skeleton sculpture, it's a whole mood that will probably make you want to watch the 2003 live-action Peter Pan the second you get home. As for the rum, find it in great cocktails like a slushy coco locos or frozen strawberry daiquiris, or in mixed drinks featuring other ingredients like honey, orange bitters, passionfruit, and pineapple. Things are relatively relaxed earlier in the night (or, rather, as relaxed as a pirate ship-themed bar can possibly be), but as it gets later, this place turns into a total party, complete with loud music and a spinning disco ball.