Where To Eat & Drink On Bainbridge Island

Here are some restaurants and bars that are a lot more exciting than a 25-minute ferry ride.

Seattle is a terrific city to live in. But sometimes you get a little stir-crazy, want to go somewhere different, and Renton isn’t going to cut it unless an afternoon testing mattresses at IKEA is your ideal escape. We have a better idea - hop the ferry to Bainbridge Island. Whether you’re spending your time here wine tasting, boutique shopping, or pretending to admire nature, these are the 13 best spots on the island no matter the situation.

The Spots

For the best Italian food on the island, drive 10 minutes north of Winslow to a little neighborhood called Rolling Bay. Via Rosa 11 is where to go to feel taken care of, and by that we mean it’s a comforting place to be fed pasta and pizza by people who pronounce “marinara” with D’s instead of R’s. Order at the counter, and then eat this excellent food inside or outside at a picnic table. While you can mix and match any pasta shape with any sauce, the best combination is fusilli with vodka sauce, and if they have the special burrata pizza with speck, you’ll want that, too.

There are quite a few boutique bakeshops on the island, but the only one you need to know about is Blackbird. This is where to go for a solid breakfast or snack to go with a latte. Even if the person in front of you sends you into a hot rage by claiming the last two slices of almond butter layer cake, there are many other delicious things to be had here - mainly, Helen’s French Roll, which is the minimalist-chic cousin to coffee cake.

This spot was formerly known as Nosh, a phenomenal food truck that served British-style pub food. The best thing about Proper Fish, though, is how enormous these entire filets of fried fish are—they’re around a foot long, with a puffy beer-battered crackle better than any state fair could achieve. That, plus tasty minted peas, thick-cut fries, and delicious tartar sauce, and there’s plenty of reasons why we’d hop on a huge watercraft to get to these fish and chips.

On busy weekends, you can always count on Bruciato to make Winslow Way smell like perfectly charred pizza crust. This pizzeria is from the same team behind Hitchcock, so you can expect a nicely-designed space that’s conducive to relaxing with Aperol spritzes and eating an abundance of buffalo mozzarella. Try it after an exhausting day of artisanal salt shopping on the main strip.

We wish we could say we’ve never met a pastrami sandwich we didn’t like, but this is Seattle, and we don’t want to lie to you. Lackluster PNW deli scene aside, the pastrami and swiss sandwich at Hitchcock Deli is worthy of introducing to your East Coast friends. Everything here is notably good and a lot of that has to do with the fact that all of the meats are smoked, cured, and roasted in-house. You could eat a sandwich on a nice plate with a cocktail in the bar area, but on a nice afternoon, a picnic with one of these and a salted cacao nib cookie is probably best practice.

The Infatuation in your inbox.

Be the first to get our newest guides & reviews, plus exclusive restaurant intel.

Jake’s Pickup is a lunch spot hidden behind racks of Doritos and gummy bears at a Chevron station where you’ll find some of the best sandwiches in Washington state. Everything here, from the sub bread to the roasted turkey is made in house, and their fried cod sandwich deserves its own radio jingle. And if you think that pulled pork and bbq sauce don’t belong with egg and cheese on a breakfast sandwich, Jake’s will prove you wrong. Don’t forget some chocolate chip sconuts (a scone donut hybrid) for the road.

Congratulations - you screwed up and thought the Seattle to Bainbridge ferry schedule was the Bainbridge to Seattle schedule, and the next boat back to the mainland isn’t for another hour. This is a perfect excuse to drink some wine, so walk back up to Winslow and have a flight at Fletcher Bay. The grapes are grown on the island, and there’s something for everyone, from the minerally Albariño to some strawberry wine that doesn’t taste like Crystal Light. The whole interior looks like a beach summer home, so naturally you might bump into a bachelorette party or three.

If you missed your ferry but aren’t a wine fan, have some beer at Bainbridge Brewing. They serve a few different types of housemade beers as well as guest taps from Seattle places like Urban Family. We like the grapefruit IPA, especially while sitting on a couch and playing board games. If you are, in fact, good at reading boat schedules and just want some beer, this is perfect for that, too.

Some of the greatest ice cream in Seattle is actually a short ferry ride away on Bainbridge Island. You’ve probably zipped past this small cottage on Winslow in favor of a certain popular spot with longer lines, but skip that line and trust us—Emma & Otto’s is way better. The beauty of their ice cream rides on its pure simplicity, from a coffee flavor that tastes like mellow cold brew swirled with fresh sweet cream to lilac-colored blackberry scoops we find hard to stop eating. (Well, licking.) A tall stack of this stuff smashed inside a homemade cinnamon waffle cone is the best treat on the island.

Right across the street from Via Rosa 11 is a little coffee shop that doubles as a flower garden and serves excellent espresso drinks in any flavor combination you could ever want. Just make sure you drink it on the patio if it’s warm out.

Emmy’s Vedge House is a solid Vietnamese takeout operation. Their menu happens to be vegan and has noodles, rice, and stir fry. Some things are better than others here, but we’re fans of anything with tofu and crispy golden rolls. It’s perfect for when you’re craving something salty but are also feeling salty about the long wait time at Bruciato.

If a spontaneous weekday off brings you to Bainbridge and you want to take a leisurely patio lunch, Restaurant Marche is a good way to go. It’s a classic French spot with good champagne, croque monsieurs, and fries with aioli. Service is on the slower side, but as long as you’re all for soaking in the island air while sipping Cuvee, you’ll have a good time.

Upon entering Rolling Bay Winery, you’ll be greeted by Alphonse, the friendly owner who will shake your hand and encourage you to drink wine immediately. He’s our kind of guy. Enjoy the wines here in a lawn chair on their grassy patio before bringing a bottle home. But not before, snacking on the free cheeses and meats available inside. The 8-year-old we saw running with flatbread crackers screaming “I can’t stop eating these” is all of us. Avoid the crowds on Winslow and do a tasting here.

Chase Sapphire Card Ad

Suggested Reading

Where To Drink With Friends From Out Of Town  guide image
Where To Drink With Friends From Out Of Town

11 bars to take visitors in Seattle.

Affordable Places To Impress An Out-Of-Towner guide image
Affordable Places To Impress An Out-Of-Towner

The best restaurants where you can impress out-of-towners without spending too much money.

Seattle’s Best Restaurants For Dinner With The Parents guide image
Seattle’s Best Restaurants For Dinner With The Parents

Your parents sat through your elementary school stage debut as “Fern #2,” and now it’s time to sit through a dinner with them. Here’s where.

The University District Guide guide image
The University District Guide

The University District isn’t just for UW undergrads. Here are the best bars and restaurants in the neighborhood.