Bay Kitchen Bar
Where we've featured it
Located up in Three Mile Harbor, on the bay just north of East Hampton and Amagansett, Bay Kitchen is your best bet for eating by the water and sunset views, without heading out to Montauk. The food here is not-cheap seafood (shocking twist, right?) and it won’t be your easiest option if you’re trying to catch a cab to the Surf Lodge afterwards, but it’s a nice setting if a pleasant dinner out is what you’re after.
The East Hampton Springs is a black hole when it comes to restaurants. There are plenty of places sitting in pristine locations right along Three Mile Harbor overlooking the bay, but none of them have ever been any good. Bay Kitchen Bar has changed that. BKB has a fish-centric menu that is very good, and a vibe that feels more beachy than cheesy. Also excellent: the view. It overlooks the bay, and may have the best sunset in all of the Hamptons.