Review

photo credit: Anne Cruz

Tortuga's Lie review image

Tortuga's Lie

$$$$

3016 S Virginia Dare Trail, Nags Head
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

You’ll probably have to wait for a table at this casual Caribbean joint, as it’s a lunch and dinner favorite with both visitors and local surfers who look like they were born with sand in their hair. Thankfully, there’s a small bar and side patio where you can enjoy beach-themed drinks that help the wait go by faster. If you’re dining solo, it’s much easier to get a spot at the bar, where you can watch sports on the nearby TVs or look on as the staff preps seafood steamers. The jerk chicken is the signature plate that’s loaded up with beans, rice, and tender chicken, but you should definitely also order the island fries and the hefty fish burrito made with whatever’s fresh that day. 

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Featured in

Where To Eat & Drink In The Outer Banks guide image
Guide
Where To Eat & Drink In The Outer Banks

From sleek new breweries in Kill Devil Hills to casual Caribbean spots in Nags Head, these are the best restaurants, cafes, and bars on North Carolina’s barrier islands.

Suggested Reading

Where To Eat & Drink In The Outer Banks guide image
Guide
Where To Eat & Drink In The Outer Banks

From sleek new breweries in Kill Devil Hills to casual Caribbean spots in Nags Head, these are the best restaurants, cafes, and bars on North Carolina’s barrier islands.

Fish Heads Bar and Grill review image
Review
Fish Heads Bar and Grill

Fish Heads Bar and Grill is a beachside bar and restaurant with great seafood, bar food, and beer in Nags Head, North Carolina.

Noosa Beach Grille review image
Review
Noosa Beach Grille

Noosa Beach Grille is an American restaurant in Kill Devil Hills that serves lunch, dinner, cocktails, and local seafood.