NYCReview

Totonno Pizzeria Napolitana review image

Totonno Pizzeria Napolitana

$$$$718-372-8606
Hours:SAT
12PM-8PM

Totonno’s is temporarily closed.

In 1924, Calvin Coolidge won a presidential election, Marlon Brando was born, and Totonno’s opened in Coney Island. And, after 90+ years, they still make an extremely good coal-oven pizza. The spot was originally opened by someone who worked at NYC’s first-ever pizza place, Lombardi’s, in Nolita. His family (mainly his granddaughters Cookie and Antoinette) still runs the show with just two menu items: small and large pies. The crust leans on the thinner side, and each pizza comes covered in equal parts cheese and tomato sauce, almost like a red-and-white leopard print. Just be sure to eat your pizza quickly, because the crust won’t stay crispy forever. This is, of course, a metaphor for life, and it’s yet another thing this old-school place in Coney Island has to offer.

Food Rundown

Pizza

It’s all about the crust out here. Thin, crispy, and charred in all the right places. Pies don’t come cheap ($21 for an eight-slice large) but the homemade mozzarella and fresh dough are well worth the splurge. We’re partial to the plain, but you also can’t go wrong by adding a few toppings here.

Totonno Pizzeria Napolitana review image

Featured in

.
The 24 Best Pizza Places In NYC guide image
Guide
The 24 Best Pizza Places In NYC

The top 24 pizzas in NYC, according to us.

Suggested Reading

.
Di Fara Pizza review image
8.9
Review
Di Fara Pizza

Brooklyn’s Di Fara is one of the best slices of pizza in New York.

L&B Spumoni Gardens review image
9.0
Review
L&B Spumoni Gardens

L&B Spumoni Gardens is an iconic Italian restaurant in Gravesend serving the best square slice and spumoni in NYC.

New Park Pizza review image
Review
New Park Pizza

Headed to JFK without a slice of pizza in your hand? Let us help you fix that. New Park Pizza is the best slice anywhere near a major transit hub in this city.

Roll N Roaster review image
8.2
Review
Roll N Roaster

Roll N Roaster is a fast food place in Sheepshead Bay that’s been around since 1971, and it specializes in roast beef sandwiches and melted cheese.