You probably know the drill here: pick your balls, sauce, and sides, and enjoy a very casual and reliable meal. The Hell’s Kitchen location has a few seats at the bar and some big communal tables in the middle for groups, and meatball heros and vegetarian balls (that actually taste good). This is an easy choice for a dinner that you don’t want to spend a lot of money on, or when you don’t feel like cooking.
Where we've featured it
More spots in Hell's KitchenSee more
When your tequila list is longer than your menu, we start to worry. The food at Añejo would be wonderful, but sadly they take the “small” in “small plates” really seriously.
Casellula is a nice little wine and cheese bar in Midtown West, perfect for a pre-theater meal.
More Italian spotsSee more
Though the food at Bacaro is pretty good, it’s the kind of place you come to for the atmosphere.
LaLou is a wine bar in Prospect Heights that’s one of our favorite spots in the city to drink natural wine.
A simple Italian cafe that works in tons of situations, Epistrophy is one of our Nolita go-tos.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more