As far as we can tell, there are three scenarios in which you might already know about The Jeffrey. 1. You’re a beer geek and you live somewhere near/under the 59th Street Bridge. 2. You stumbled upon it as you were desperately trying to escape Bed Bath & Beyond, running in any direction that promised the fastest route to freedom. 3. You saw it in our 2014 Summer Guide. Otherwise, this is probably the first time you’re hearing about this little gem located under the Roosevelt Island Tram.
The thing is, once you do make it into The Jeffrey, and regardless of the circumstances that brought you to it, you’ll be coming back. This place is easily the best bar in 20 blocks in any direction, and they also happen to have a great food menu and a big backyard beer garden. We have found ourselves visiting The Jeffrey whenever we’re in need of something Midtown or Upper East Side with outdoor seating, or when we’re looking for a spot to watch a game. The sandwiches and bar food bites are solid, the atmosphere is laid back, the beer list is huge, and the staff is friendly.
I think what we like most about The Jeffrey, though, is that there’s another layer beyond all of those things I just mentioned. In addition to the beer and the beer garden and the nice TV situation, there’s also an interesting little espresso bar and cocktail “lab” on one side of the space. This area has its own separate entrance, and is presided over by a man they call “The Bearded Alchemist.” As you can probably imagine, The Bearded Alchemist is awesome, and he makes excellent drinks, often incorporating unique ingredients like homemade ginger beer and mole bitters. During the daylight hours, this section of the bar also offers high quality coffee and growlers of beer to-go. The fact that those things are even available to you in this neighborhood make The Jeffrey unique and are also a testament to the fact that it’s much more than just a beer garden - it’s an escape. Just plan your getaway wisely. They designed that Bed Bath & Beyond so that it’s nearly impossible to get out. Like a prison. With Swiffers.
Sign up for our newsletter.
Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.
These are actually Sigmund’s pretzels, and if you haven’t had them before, they’re pretty great. You have three options available to you - salted, garlic and parsley, or truffle cheddar. We usually go for all three and share them.
Red Beet Deviled Eggs
Bright red, a little bit earthy, and pretty damn tasty. Order them if you like beets and/or eggs.
Devils On Horseback
Bacon wrapped dates. These are sweet and salty, as they should be. Great as a snack to go with that 11% IPA you’re sipping on.
The Jeffrey Reubenstein
A very solid reuben with an IPA mustard that has a unique flavor. You can’t go wrong with this one.
We like the BLT at The Jeffrey because there’s a layer of egg salad on top of the bacon, and we’re fans of putting things we like on top of things we like.
There’s usually a good selection of oysters on hand here. We had some Wellfleets on a recent visit, and they usually have a West Coast variety or two as well.