Sushi Kaito review image

Sushi Kaito

Kaito on West 72nd Street serves a 15-course omakase for less than $100 that’s especially great because it doesn’t follow the same progression as most other high-end options in the neighborhood. Every two or three nigiri rounds will be broken up by a cooked dish like tempura fried hake in a mushroom broth and maybe a smoked goldeneye snapper collar if you’re lucky. The sushi tends to lean traditional here, usually with some alley oops from yuzu, dark soy, or scallions. But the sushi chefs behind the 10-seat counter slice the fish notably thicker than what you may have seen elsewhere. When you’re eating hefty pieces of king salmon, Japanese mackerel with ginger on top, or sweet shrimp with yuzu zest, you’ll really feel like you’re getting your money’s worth (and also like your mouth has an entire fish in it, with no fishy-funky taste whatsoever). Thanks to the larger prepared dishes, the 15-course tasting feels like a substantial amount of food. If you want to try even more pieces, there’s an 18-course option for $135.

Featured in

Where To Eat Omakase Sushi In NYC For Under $100 guide image
Where To Eat Omakase Sushi In NYC For Under $100

Our favorite high-end sushi meals that cost less than what you'd pay for a set of AirPods.

The Best Restaurants On The Upper West Side guide image
The Best Restaurants On The Upper West Side

Our favorite Upper West Side restaurants for all sorts of dining situations.

The Best Sushi In NYC guide image
The Best Sushi In NYC

From our favorite places to eat omakase sushi to some top-tier neighborhood spots, here's where to have a big night out.

Suggested Reading

Sushi Noz review image
Sushi Noz

You want the short version of this review? The cheapest meal at Sushi Noz costs $250, and it’s worth the price.

Sushi Nonaka review image
Sushi Nonaka

High-quality sushi, a garden patio, and an omakase for under $100 make Sushi Nonaka one of the best secrets on the Upper West Side.

Tanoshi Sushi review image
Tanoshi Sushi

Tanoshi Sushi is a reasonably-priced, BYOB omakase spot on the Upper East Side that offers interesting add-on nigiri.