NYCReview

photo credit: Sugar Hill Creamery

Sugar Hill Creamery review image

Sugar Hill Creamery

Perfect For:Birthdays

We don’t hand out awards for ice cream names, but if we did, Sugar Hill Creamery’s A$AP Rocky Road would probably receive some sort of recognition. But you need to order it for the name alone. It’s stuffed with hazelnuts, marshmallows, brownies, and graham crackers, and it’s exactly what you want all over your face on a warm day in Harlem. Or, if you prefer, you can also get some peach cobbler, blueberry cheesecake, or strawberry ice cream with basil and lemon curds. The important thing is that you come here and eat ice cream. It’s some of the best in the city.

Featured in

.
The Best Ice Cream In NYC guide image
Guide
The Best Ice Cream In NYC

For a scoop of something cold, here’s where to go.

Suggested Reading

.
Melba’s review image
8.3
Review
Melba’s

Melba’s is a spot in Harlem with some great fried chicken, catfish, and waffles. Try it for a casual meal, and get a side of mac and cheese.

Jacob Restaurant review image
Review
Jacob Restaurant

Jacob Restaurant is a buffet in Harlem where you can fill a styrofoam container with some very solid soul food and Caribbean food.

Archer & Goat review image
Review
Archer & Goat

Archer & Goat is a restaurant/bar in the bottom of a townhouse in Harlem. It’s a good spot for a drink and a snack, and it has a nice little backyard.

Red Rooster review image
Review
Red Rooster

Few restaurants in this city feel as alive as Red Rooster in Harlem - the atmosphere is incredible.