NYCReview

photo credit: Henry Hargreaves

Smith & Wollensky review image
8.0

Smith & Wollensky

$$$$

797 3rd Ave, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points
RESERVE A TABLE

POWERED BY

open table

This restaurant isn’t trying to be anything other than a classic and reliable steakhouse, and that’s exactly what it is. You’ll see white tablecloths, wine bottles stored everywhere, and servers wheeling out plates on carts throughout the large, two-story space. The huge martinis are properly chilled, the clams casino is pleasingly salty from all the bacon, and the simple house caesar is prepared exactly as it should be.

But what about the steaks? The massive prime rib, which comes with its bone, is juicy and has an intense beefy flavor. However, the bone-in dry-aged filet is the surprise winner here. Every picture-perfect slice with a deep brown crust and an ideal pink-and-red middle is so indulgent that you won’t mind that you're eating such a lean cut. 

Henry Hargreaves

Smith & Wollensky review image

If you order correctly, you won’t have room for dessert. Doesn’t matter—the moist coconut cake is a must. The rectangular slice (with pineapples and mango ice cream) is cut like it’s from the middle of a cake. That means there isn’t one edge with a lot more frosting, making this dessert less of a sugar bomb overall.

Smith & Wollensky’s recognizable green and white facade has been a fixture in Midtown East for over 40 years, and given how endearing their straightforward approach to serving steak is, it’ll probably be around for at least 40 more.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Featured in

The Best Steakhouses In NYC guide image
Guide
The Best Steakhouses In NYC

From a few NYC classics to some relatively new spots that are big on TikTok, here are our favorite places to eat a medium-rare porterhouse.

Where To Get A Business Lunch When Your Company Is Paying guide image
Guide
Where To Get A Business Lunch When Your Company Is Paying

14 spots perfect for impressing clients or colleagues (and not worrying about the check).

Suggested Reading

Gallaghers Steakhouse review image
9.0
Review
Gallaghers Steakhouse

Gallaghers Steakhouse has been serving exceptionally good dry-aged meats in Times Square since the 1940s. It's the best classic steakhouse experience in NYC.

Keens Steakhouse review image
8.6
Review
Keens Steakhouse

Keens is a classic Midtown steakhouse filled with historical artifacts. Even if you don’t care about Albert Einstein’s smoking pipe, you’ll have a great meal here.

The Grill review image
Review
The Grill

The Grill is the revamp of the legendary Four Seasons restaurant, run by the people behind Carbone. It’s very similar, very expensive, and worth it.