Ever watch a random movie on a plane? Usually it's something harmless, a romantic comedy with bright colors and attractive people. Maybe you laughed a few times. Afterwards, you thought, "Well, that was 'cute' enough." It wasn't anything particularly memorable, and somewhere deep down you held on to the sense you could probably have made better use of you time. But with a glass of alcohol in your hand and nowhere else to be, you felt fine about things.
This has been our experience at Rosie's, a big Mexican restaurant in the East Village: it's a perfectly OK place to have a good time, but relatively unmemorable overall. On multiple visits, we didn't walk away feeling like we needed to order anything we'd eaten again. Most of it wasn't bad, it was just not all that exciting.
The restaurant is the newest project from the chefs behind Cookshop and Vic's, but it has more in common with the nearby "well, that was definitely fine" Vic's than it does with the original "that place was actually great" Cookshop. The space is big and open, decorated with what are essentially glorified string lights, giving the whole place kind of backyard party on Pinterest vibe. If it's warm out, the doors are all open to the street, and there's an outdoor seating area that makes 2nd Avenue actually feel pretty nice. It's a good space in which to drink tequila and eat some guacamole, just don't expect to be wowed by the majority of the food.
Put it this way: is this a restaurant you should go out of your way to make a reservation at? No. But if you end up here because your friend booked it for their birthday party? (And someone is inevitably going to book it for their birthday party). You'll be fine.
Sign up for our newsletter.
Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.
Coctele De Mariscos
This was pitched hard to us, and it's essentially Bloody Mary mix with some seafood mixed in, in a root beer float glass, with Saltines on the side. Sure. We didn't love the thick sauce, and would not endorse ordering this again.
Tostada De Salpicon De Dorado
These are crunchy tostadas, but ones the size of chips, topped with some very fishy mahi mahi. We'd do an extra order of tacos over these.
A very respectable fish taco. We're not handing out awards here, but this does the trick.
Al Pastor Taco
Again, a solid taco. Not the best, but a decent al pastor. Tacos are the move here.
Pescado En Su Jugo
A whole porgy, in a tomato/chile/orange sauce. The fish was light and tasty for a few bites, but nobody wanted to finish this.
A sliced marinated skirt steak is usually a good order. That's the case here: it's one of the better entrees. It comes with some onions and guacamole.
Yep, these are great. All churros are good. The churros that the lady sells on the L train platform are probably good. Anyway, churros. Get 'em.