I’m not quite sure what it is, but there’s something particularly enticing about a piping hot Reggiano’s pie that always makes me rip open the box to eat a slice or three while I’m stuck in traffic on the BQE. Yes, I end up covered in crumbs from the charred, cracker-thin crust by the end of the journey, but I’m also full and happy. The arugula-sausage pie is my absolute favorite, with fresh mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, and Italian sausage, plus a hardy serving of fresh arugula and a finishing splash of olive oil.
Where we've featured it
More spots in Staten IslandSee more
The Pizza Parlor
The Pizza Parlor on Staten Island is a classic pizzeria with a great Grandma-style pie.
Flagship Brewing Co.
Flagship Brewing is where you should be getting your craft beer needs met on Staten Island.
Lakruwana is a Sri Lankan restaurant on Staten Island with a $15 all-you-can-eat buffet and outdoor seating.
More Italian spotsSee more
Pizza by Lucille’s
Pizza By Lucille’s is a great slice shop in Harlem. You can’t go wrong here, but we especially love the square slices.
If you’re looking to have an amazing romantic dinner with some of the best Italian food this city has to offer, keep looking. But if you’re just looking to go out with a big group, celebrate a birthday, and have a really good time, Gemma will do.
Noodle Pudding is a cash-only Italian restaurant near the Brooklyn Bridge. The pastas are always reliable, and the vibe is Perfect For Sunday Dinner.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more