Pietro Nolita review image

Pietro Nolita


174 Elizabeth St, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points


open table

Everything at Pietro Nolita, and we mean everything, is millennial pink. Even if you were to somehow forget about all the pink in the restaurant, the napkins that read “Pink As F*ck” will remind you. (So will the t-shirts and bandanas available for purchase.) Pietro Nolita’s commitment to pink is not what makes this Italian cafe upsetting, though. There's nothing inherently wrong with pink or a fierce dedication to a theme—but this restaurant is only pink to distract you from its oily, acid-less kale salads, gluey cacio e pepe, and gin cocktails that taste as Pepto-Bismol-like as the walls look. Of all the restaurant’s details, our favorite was the unboxed Hilary Clinton action figure doll resting on the shelf by the door. In the corner of the box it says “2016 Or Bust.” No better metaphor for this sunken Girlboss place exists. 

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.

By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Suggested Reading

Altro Paradiso review image
Altro Paradiso

You don’t have to play tennis or own a beach house to love this West Soho Italian cafe, you’ll just embody that energy while you’re here.

Skirt Steak review image
Skirt Steak

Skirt Steak’s concept is pretty simple: Make people wait in line, and then reward them with steak, peppercorn bearnaise, and unlimited fries. 

Epistrophy Cafe review image
Epistrophy Cafe

A simple Italian cafe that works in tons of situations, Epistrophy is one of our Nolita go-tos.