NYCReview

Pen 'n' Coop review image

Pen 'n' Coop

Perfect For:LunchQuick Eats

$$$$

601 W 26th St, New York
Earn 3X Points

Despite Pen n’ Coop’s insistence on describing themselves as an “Italian street food meets NYC deli” concept, this vendor in Chelsea food hall Olly Olly Market isn’t reinventing the wheel. They’re just a solid sandwich shop that deals in rotisserie chicken and porchetta, with a couple vegetarian options thrown in. The Mr. Cooper sandwich does a good job with the classic combo of pesto, burrata, roasted red peppers, and decently moist chicken on a crusty roll, but it could use a bit more meat.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Featured in

What To Eat (And Skip) At Olly Olly Market feature image
Feature
What To Eat (And Skip) At Olly Olly Market

At this food hall in Chelsea, you can get a quick lunch, have a drink, or try your luck at snagging a cult-favorite scallion pancake burrito.

Suggested Reading

Forsyth Fire Escape review image
7.8
Review
Forsyth Fire Escape

Forsyth Fire Escape's scallion pancake burrito is the most coveted item at Chelsea's Olly Olly Market. Is it worth the hour-long wait?

What To Eat (And Skip) At The Tin Building By Jean-Georges feature image
Feature
What To Eat (And Skip) At The Tin Building By Jean-Georges

Here's what we think of all the places at the massive Seaport food hall from Jean-Georges Vongerichten.

The Best Restaurants In Chelsea guide image
Guide
The Best Restaurants In Chelsea

Where you should be eating in SW3.