NYCReview

Omakase Room By Tatsu review image

Omakase Room by Tatsu

Tolerance for group trips can vary widely. Some people have an internal meltdown when a company bowling outing is so much as mentioned, while others might be the enthusiastic ringleaders of a family reunion taking place on a cruise ship. We’re skeptical of those people on the cruise ship wavelength, but we also know that doing things with other human beings in an organized manner can sometimes be a good thing.

Omakase Room By Tatsu is a sushi place that’s sort of like a group trip, but without flip flops and nametags and with absolutely zero screaming. At this quiet, below-ground spot in the West Village, you and nine other people will be asked to arrive at precisely 6, 7:30, or 9pm. In the 90 minutes that follow, the 10 of you will receive, almost in unison, 18 pieces of top-quality, simply prepared sushi. You’ll order some sake or wine of your own choosing, but otherwise, this is a sushi meal that follows a close script. Fortunately, the sushi is very good, and you won’t be disappointed in the dozen and a half pieces that get placed in front of you.

While the choreographed, carefully-timed production makes for a nice meal with no real flaws, the strict 90-minute time frame does add pressure, and doesn’t allow for much cushion to finish off your sake leisurely. For $145 before tax and tip, it can feel like a short evening that you’re a bit rushed out of. Especially when your coat is brought over as you’re paying the check.

Of course, in most ways, Omakase Room By Tatsu is absolutely nothing like a group trip. For one, it’s extremely quiet, and there’s no music playing. That, paired with the minimalist space, makes this restaurant feel like a place you should sit up straight, pay attention, and refrain from using curse words.

Omakase Room By Tatsu serves a traditional omakase sushi meal that sushi purists in particular will enjoy. And if someone is nice enough to invite you, you’re in for some expertly-prepared fish. But for the price, there are other places we’d be more likely to go back to for a dinner without the restrained time frame, which are a bit more suited to a celebratory occasion.

Food Rundown

Omakase

The 18-piece meal here is all nigiri sushi, with minimal accoutrements. The oyster, uni, and salmon that’s smoked in a box in front of you are highlights.

Omakase Room By Tatsu review image

Omakase Room By Tatsu review image

Omakase Room By Tatsu review image

Featured in

.
NYC Restaurants With New Takeout & Delivery Options guide image
Guide
NYC Restaurants With New Takeout & Delivery Options

Find something great to eat for dinner at home, and support NYC restaurants while you’re at it.

Suggested Reading

.
Sushi Katsuei review image
8.4
Review
Sushi Katsuei

This is the second location of the Park Slope spot where you can get some excellent, relatively affordable sushi.

Sushi Nakazawa review image
Review
Sushi Nakazawa

How much will you like the West Village's Sushi Nakazawa? How much money do you have, and how recently did you watch Jiro Dreams of Sushi?

Sushi Seki Chelsea review image
Review
Sushi Seki Chelsea

The Chelsea Sushi Seki outpost is bigger and badder than the original. Aside from the decor differences, everything appears to be exactly the same.

Ushiwakamaru review image
Review
Ushiwakamaru

Ushiwakamaru is now in Chelsea, in a fancier space with higher prices. It's still a top notch sushi option.